When Corporate Disputes Belong in the RTC, Not the Sandiganbayan

PCGG involvement does not automatically place a corporate dispute in Sandiganbayan; intra-corporate controversies belong before designated RTC courts. A corporation challenging a government-held shareholder interest cannot automatically go to the Sandiganbayan simply because the Presidential Commission on Good Government is involved. When the dispute concerns shareholder rights, board conflicts, capital stock, or stock exchange listing […]

Stockholders Can Enforce Corporate Inspection Rights in the RTC Even When Sequestered Companies Are Involved

Stockholders may enforce inspection rights in the RTC when the dispute is intra-corporate, even if the company has sequestration history. Stockholders and corporate representatives do not lose the ordinary remedy of enforcing inspection rights merely because a corporation has a sequestration history or a factional board dispute. When the controversy is about corporate books, board […]

Fake Tax Credit Certificates Do Not Stop the Government from Collecting Customs Duties

The Supreme Court held that pending Sandiganbayan criminal cases do not bar the Government from separately collecting unpaid customs duties based on spurious tax credits. A taxpayer cannot block the Government from collecting customs duties and taxes merely because related criminal cases over allegedly spurious tax credit certificates are still pending. When the liability sought […]

GOCC Subsidiary Officers Cannot Avoid Sandiganbayan Jurisdiction by Invoking Corporation Code Incorporation

GOCC subsidiary officers may face Sandiganbayan graft cases even if the corporation was formed under the Corporation Code, not a special charter. Officers of government-owned or controlled corporate subsidiaries may face Sandiganbayan prosecution for graft even when their company was incorporated under the Corporation Code rather than created by a special charter. The practical consequence […]

GOCC Managers Cannot Avoid Sandiganbayan Cases by Pointing to Salary Grade

GOCC managers may face Sandiganbayan trial despite Salary Grade 26 when their position is expressly covered and the alleged graft relates to office. Managers and directors of government-owned or controlled corporations may fall within the Sandiganbayan’s jurisdiction even if their salary grade is below Grade 27. The practical lesson is direct: for anti-graft cases involving […]

Selling Government Property Too Cheap Can Become an Anti-Graft Case

Government asset sales at suspiciously low prices can trigger anti-graft liability when public officers intervene and the transaction disadvantages the government. Public officers who dispose of government property at an unreasonably low price, without proper authority, bidding, valuation, and documentation, may face criminal liability even if the transaction is presented as an ordinary sale of […]

Sandiganbayan Cannot Hear Every PCGG-Related Corporate Dispute

The Supreme Court held that Sandiganbayan cannot hear prohibition, mandamus, or quo warranto petitions without an express legal grant of jurisdiction. Not every dispute involving a sequestered corporation belongs in the Sandiganbayan. Even when the Presidential Commission on Good Government participates in, influences, or prompts a corporate act, a party seeking prohibition, mandamus, or quo […]

When PCGG Sequestration Disputes Must Go to the Sandiganbayan

PCGG-related corporate disputes tied to sequestration belong before the Sandiganbayan, but shareholders retain inspection rights in sequestered firms. Businesses and shareholders affected by PCGG sequestration cannot split related disputes among different forums: challenges to PCGG acts, board takeovers, corporate records, injunctions, and related provisional remedies must generally be brought before the Sandiganbayan when they arise […]

When Government Buys a Private Corporation, Its Officers May Face Anti-Graft Jurisdiction

Government-acquired corporations may fall under anti-graft jurisdiction when public funds and government functions transform their accountability status. Corporate officers and employees cannot avoid anti-graft investigation merely because their company began as a private corporation. When the government acquires a corporation to perform government-related functions, that corporation may become government-owned or controlled for purposes of public […]

Judges and Court Employees Can Still Face Anti-Graft Prosecution Before the Sandiganbayan

Court personnel remain subject to Sandiganbayan anti-graft prosecution despite limits on administrative investigations by the Tanodbayan. Public officers cannot avoid anti-graft prosecution merely because they work in the courts. The key doctrine is jurisdictional separation: administrative supervision over judges and court personnel belongs to the Supreme Court, but criminal prosecution for offenses cognizable by the […]