Missed Projections Are Not Always Securities Fraud: When Corporate Officers Avoid Criminal Liability

The Supreme Court held that missed project projections are not automatically securities fraud, absent the right charge and proof linking officers to the violation. Corporate officers are not automatically criminally liable when a company misses a projected business milestone stated in a registration statement. A future completion date, standing alone, is not an untrue statement […]

When Corporate Mismanagement Triggers SEC Intervention: Minority Stockholders Can Ask the Regulator to Step In

The Supreme Court upheld SEC power to investigate corporate mismanagement and create a management committee despite intra-corporate allegations. Minority stockholders are not confined to ordinary intra-corporate litigation when alleged corporate mismanagement threatens company assets, public interest, or the survival of the business itself. The Supreme Court recognized that the Securities and Exchange Commission may still […]

Late SEC Reports Can Cost a Company Its Right to Sell Securities

Repeated SEC filing defaults may justify revocation of securities registration when the issuer had notice, warning, and a chance to explain. Companies that repeatedly fail to file required SEC reports cannot rely on a missing second hearing to undo the revocation of their securities registration, so long as they were warned, given a meaningful chance […]

Proxy Fights Over Corporate Director Elections Belong in Court, Not the SEC

Proxy disputes tied to director elections belong in regular courts, not the SEC, even when framed as proxy-solicitation violations. Stockholders challenging proxies used to elect corporate directors must bring the dispute before the regular courts, not the Securities and Exchange Commission. Even when the objection is framed as a violation of SEC proxy-solicitation rules, the […]

Corporate Disputes Can Proceed Separately From SEC Fraud Investigations

The Court held that SEC fraud investigations and intra-corporate disputes may proceed separately when they involve different causes, reliefs, and forums. Corporate officers and shareholders accused of irregular stock issuances cannot automatically stop one proceeding simply because another complaint involving the same corporation is already pending. When one case attacks the validity of corporate meetings […]