When Suspicion Is Not Enough: How Corporations Must Prove Fraud in Share Transfers

Suspicion alone cannot void a share transfer. Fraud must be proven clearly, and stock ownership may exist before the certificate is issued. A corporation that suspects insider dealing in the sale and resale of its shares cannot recover damages or undo the transaction on suspicion alone. Fraud must be pleaded and proven by clear and […]

A Court Order Is Not Enough: Why Injunction Bonds Can Decide Corporate Control Fights

The Supreme Court held that a preliminary injunction needs a timely bond before it can stop a corporate share sale or support contempt claims. A party trying to stop a disputed corporate share sale must do more than obtain an order saying the sale should be enjoined; the required injunction bond must be filed and […]

When Informal Payments Are Not Salary: Lessons on Stock Sales, Donations, and Corporate Records

A shareholder who accepted full payment could not undo a stock sale despite irregular records; informal salary claims may be treated as void donations. Corporate shareholders cannot use irregular stock-transfer paperwork to undo a sale they knowingly accepted, especially after receiving the full purchase price and allowing the transaction to stand for years. For business […]

When Share Recovery Claims Come Too Late: Prescription, Constructive Trust, and Missing Parties in Corporate Share Disputes

Share recovery claims over corporate stock must be timely filed against indispensable parties; constructive trust cannot cure stale or misdirected suits. Claims to recover corporate shares cannot be revived simply by labeling a later holder as a constructive trustee. When the dispute concerns movable property such as shares of stock, a claimant must sue the […]

When a Stock Sale Fight Belongs Before the SEC, Not the Trial Court

Share transfer and corporate control disputes belong before the SEC when they affect ownership, voting rights, directors, and corporate governance. Corporate control disputes cannot be disguised as ordinary civil cases when the real fight is over who owns, votes, records, or controls shares in a corporation. The doctrine from the Abejo-Braga controversy is straightforward but […]