When Corporate Control Is Disputed, Courts Cannot Use Injunctions to Decide the Boardroom War Early

A disputed corporate election cannot justify injunction without a clear legal right, especially where estate shares, voting authority, and quorum remain unresolved. A faction claiming control of a corporation cannot obtain a preliminary injunction merely by presenting a disputed election as presumptively valid. When the right to manage the company depends on contested voting rights, […]

Debt-to-Equity Conversion Can Shift Corporate Control When the Records Prove It

Debt converted into shares can validly shift corporate control when supported by records; fraud and due process claims require proof, not suspicion. A shareholder challenging a debt-to-equity conversion must prove more than suspicion: once corporate records, stock ledgers, financial statements, and creditor confirmations show that debt was converted into shares, the resulting majority ownership may […]

When Corporate Stock Records Are Incomplete, Shareholders May Still Prove Ownership and Voting Rights

Shareholders may prove voting rights through articles and other records when the stock and transfer book is incomplete, affecting quorum and control. Shareholders are not automatically stripped of voting rights simply because their names, or their predecessors’ names, do not appear in the corporation’s stock and transfer book. Where the corporation’s articles of incorporation, conduct, […]

Non-Voting Shares Are Not Automatic: Why Stock Classifications Cannot Strip Ordinary Shareholders of Control

Ordinary shares cannot be stripped of voting rights unless validly classified as preferred or redeemable; the Court protected Class B shareholders’ control rights. Corporations cannot make ordinary shares practically powerless simply by labeling them as a separate class. Unless a share is validly classified and issued as preferred or redeemable, the shareholder generally keeps the […]

Sequestered Shares Do Not Give the Government Automatic Control of a Corporation

Sequestration preserves disputed shares but does not automatically let the PCGG vote them or control a corporation without proof of ill-gotten wealth and dissipation risk. Sequestration does not make the government the owner of private shares, and the PCGG cannot use seized stock to control a corporation unless it first shows both a prima facie […]

Stock Buyers Cannot Vote Until the Stock Certificate Is Properly Endorsed and Delivered

Share transferees cannot vote or challenge corporate elections without proper endorsement, delivery, and recording of stock transfers in corporate books. A person who buys or receives shares in a Philippine corporation does not automatically acquire the right to vote, attend stockholders’ meetings, or challenge corporate elections unless the transfer complies with the formal requirements for […]

Stock Transfers Must Be Registered Before Buyers Can Vote or Control the Corporation

Share buyers cannot vote against the corporation until transfers are recorded in corporate books; injunction may preserve control during disputes. A buyer of corporate shares does not automatically become a voting stockholder against the corporation simply because a deed of sale has been signed. Until the transfer is recorded in the corporate books, the corporation […]

Cancelled Stock Certificates Cannot Defeat a Valid Corporate Dissolution Vote

Shareholders with real two-thirds stock ownership may approve dissolution; void or simulated stock transfers cannot defeat their voting rights. Corporate shareholders who validly hold at least two-thirds of a corporation’s outstanding capital stock may approve voluntary dissolution, and management cannot defeat that vote by relying on simulated, undocumented, or void stock transfers that were later […]