Shareholder Derivative Suits Can Be Dismissed When Investors Skip Internal Corporate Remedies

Minority shareholders must plead specific exhausted corporate remedies before filing a derivative suit; letters and meetings alone may not be enough. Minority stockholders cannot use a derivative suit as a first resort when they have not pleaded, with particularity, the internal corporate remedies they tried and failed to exhaust. For business owners, directors, corporate secretaries, […]

When a Stock Trading Dispute Belongs in Regular Court, Not a Special Commercial Court

The Supreme Court held that an investor’s unauthorized-trading claim against a broker is an ordinary civil action, not automatically an intra-corporate case. Investors who sue a securities broker for unauthorized trades, missing funds, or the return of shares are not automatically dragged into special commercial court procedure simply because the dispute involves stocks. If the […]

When a Special Commercial Court Can Still Hear an Ordinary Injunction Case

A Special Commercial Court remains an RTC with jurisdiction over ordinary injunction cases, including condominium property disputes not involving intra-corporate rights. A case should not be dismissed merely because it was assigned to a Regional Trial Court branch designated as a Special Commercial Court. If the complaint is an ordinary civil action for injunction and […]

When Share Transfers Become Corporate Fraud: Why Stockholders Can Sue in Special Commercial Courts

Share-transfer disputes that affect stockholder status and corporate control may be intra-corporate cases heard by Special Commercial Courts. A corporation that is allegedly stripped of its shares through an unauthorized loan, pledge, auction sale, and stock transfer may treat the dispute as an intra-corporate controversy when the controversy affects its status, voting power, and participation […]

Heirs Cannot Use a Corporate Case to Divide Inherited Shares Before Estate Settlement

Heirs disputing inherited corporate shares must pursue estate settlement, not a commercial or derivative suit, when the real issue is succession and partition. Heirs claiming ownership of shares in a family corporation cannot shortcut probate by filing a corporate case for accounting, derivative relief, or alleged corporate fraud. When the real dispute is who among […]