Coal Operators Can Still Recover VAT Wrongly Withheld Despite Later VAT Law Amendments

Coal operators under PD 972 may recover VAT wrongly withheld because RA 9337 did not repeal special-law tax exemptions recognized by the NIRC. Coal operators with tax incentives under a valid Coal Operating Contract may still be exempt from value-added tax, and VAT wrongly withheld from their coal sales may be recovered as a refund […]

Coal Operators May Still Claim VAT Exemption Under Special Laws Despite Later Tax Amendments

Special-law tax exemptions may survive later VAT amendments, allowing Semirara to recover wrongly withheld VAT despite BIR documentation objections. Coal operators covered by a valid coal operating contract may remain exempt from VAT when that exemption is granted by a special law, even if a later tax statute removes coal from the general list of […]

PAL MCIT Exemption Rule: When Franchise Tax Options Defeat MCIT

Special franchise taxpayers may defeat MCIT when the law gives a lower-tax option and an in-lieu-of-all-other-taxes clause. The PAL MCIT Exemption Rule protects a taxpayer with a special legislative franchise from being forced into the minimum corporate income tax when its franchise gives it a narrower and more favorable tax choice. For companies operating under […]