Lost Customs Shipment Rule: When BOC Must Pay Importers

BOC may pay importers for lost seized goods using the exchange rate at actual payment, and cannot hide behind state immunity. The Lost Customs Shipment Rule means that an importer whose goods disappear while under Bureau of Customs custody may recover the value of the shipment, and that value may be converted into pesos using […]

Infrastructure TRO Ban: Limits on Blocking Public Projects

Lower courts cannot stop national infrastructure bidding by TRO, but may still hear proper cases challenging illegal public project awards. Public infrastructure projects cannot be stopped by a temporary restraining order from a lower court merely because a taxpayer questions the bidding process. The Infrastructure TRO Ban Doctrine means that trial courts may still hear […]

When PCGG Sequestration Disputes Must Go to the Sandiganbayan

PCGG-related corporate disputes tied to sequestration belong before the Sandiganbayan, but shareholders retain inspection rights in sequestered firms. Businesses and shareholders affected by PCGG sequestration cannot split related disputes among different forums: challenges to PCGG acts, board takeovers, corporate records, injunctions, and related provisional remedies must generally be brought before the Sandiganbayan when they arise […]

When a Government Contract Cannot Be Sued On: State Immunity in Military Base Projects

A foreign state may avoid suit over military-base contracts when the work is sovereign, not commercial, even if private bidding and contractor dealings occurred. A private contractor cannot automatically sue a foreign government in Philippine courts merely because the dispute arose from bidding, procurement, or project work. When the transaction is tied to a sovereign […]

When Foreign Military Officials Can Claim State Immunity in Philippine Courts

Foreign military officers may be immune from Philippine suits when challenged acts are official, treaty-based, and effectively actions of a foreign sovereign. A lawsuit in the Philippines may be dismissed when it is, in substance, an action against a foreign sovereign for acts performed by its officer under an international agreement. The Baer ruling teaches […]