When Suspicion Is Not Enough: How Corporations Must Prove Fraud in Share Transfers

Suspicion alone cannot void a share transfer. Fraud must be proven clearly, and stock ownership may exist before the certificate is issued. A corporation that suspects insider dealing in the sale and resale of its shares cannot recover damages or undo the transaction on suspicion alone. Fraud must be pleaded and proven by clear and […]

Cancelled Stock Certificates Cannot Defeat a Valid Corporate Dissolution Vote

Shareholders with real two-thirds stock ownership may approve dissolution; void or simulated stock transfers cannot defeat their voting rights. Corporate shareholders who validly hold at least two-thirds of a corporation’s outstanding capital stock may approve voluntary dissolution, and management cannot defeat that vote by relying on simulated, undocumented, or void stock transfers that were later […]

A Club Cannot Use Hidden By-Laws to Defeat a Bank’s Pledge

A corporation cannot use undisclosed by-laws or monthly dues to defeat a good-faith bank’s pledge and foreclosure of a shareholder’s club share. A corporation cannot rely on internal by-laws that were unknown to a good-faith third party to defeat a valid pledge, foreclosure, or transfer of a share. For lenders, stockholders, club members, and taxpayers […]

Lost Stock Certificates Are Not Ordinary Civil Claims: Why Stockholders Must Bring Replacement Disputes to the Corporate Forum

A stockholder’s claim for replacement of a missing stock certificate is an intra-corporate controversy, and damages do not move it to ordinary courts. Stockholders who are refused a replacement stock certificate cannot automatically turn that dispute into an ordinary damages case in the regular courts. When the controversy is fundamentally between a stockholder and the […]