Corporations Cannot Simply Cut a Stockholder’s Shares Without Paying for Them

Supreme Court voided a faction’s reduction of fully paid shares, stressing treasury-share rules, retained earnings, and trust fund doctrine. A majority stockholder’s shares cannot be reduced by boardroom maneuver, factional vote, or informal agreement unless the corporation complies with the strict rules on treasury shares, retained earnings, capital reduction, and consideration. For business owners and […]

When Share Ownership Is Disputed, Corporate Books Cannot Be Used as a Litigation Shortcut

A registered stockholder’s inspection rights cannot be defeated by merely alleging disputed share ownership. The case remains intra-corporate until ownership is resolved. A corporation cannot avoid a registered stockholder’s demand to inspect corporate books simply by recasting the dispute as a private ownership fight over shares. Where the parties appear in corporate records as stockholders […]

When a Corporate By-Law Is Fixed, the Court May Refuse to Decide the Fight

A corrected corporate by-law can moot a governance case, leaving courts unable to issue advisory rulings on SEC powers or board election disputes. A corporate governance case can disappear before judgment when the corporation corrects the challenged by-law and no practical relief remains for the parties. For companies, stockholders, and directors, the ruling teaches a […]

Stockholders Can Prove Ownership Without a Stock Certificate

The Court held that stock ownership may be proven without a stock certificate, allowing shareholders to pursue inspection and corporate record claims. Corporate shareholders are not automatically stripped of inspection rights merely because they cannot produce a stock certificate in their own name. When a person can show subscriptions, payments, corporate records, SEC filings, minutes, […]

When Withholding Corporate Books Becomes a Criminal Case

Refusal to inspect a stock and transfer book may be criminal, but only if the accused acted for the corporation in denying statutory inspection rights. Stockholders and directors have a legally enforceable right to inspect a corporation’s records, minutes, and stock and transfer book, but a criminal prosecution for denial of that right will prosper […]

When Shareholders Demand an Audit: Court Orders, Corporate Books, and the Risk of Contempt

Court-ordered audits in corporate disputes must be obeyed while effective, but contempt consequences may become moot when the main case is dismissed. Corporate officers who resist a court-ordered inspection or audit of company books may face contempt proceedings while the order remains effective, but if the main case that gave rise to the audit is […]