Consultation Creates Counsel: Lawyer Ethics SC Ruling

A lawyer-client relationship can arise from consultation alone, making conflicts, misuse of client documents, and heir exclusion sanctionable. The Consultation Creates Counsel Doctrine means that a lawyer-client relationship may arise even without a written retainer agreement or payment of legal fees. For clients, once a lawyer accepts a consultation for professional advice, the lawyer already […]

When Retirement Benefits Become an Inheritance Fight: Proof of Filiation Controls Who Gets Paid

The Supreme Court held that GSIS retirement and leave benefits must be paid only to legally proven heirs, rejecting weak proof of marriage or filiation. Families claiming retirement, salary, leave, and allowance benefits of a deceased government employee cannot rely on sympathy, family stories, baptismal records, or informal recognition alone. When competing heirs claim public-sector […]

Probate Judges Can Be Disciplined for Ignoring Obvious Red Flags in a Will

A probate judge may face discipline for ignoring obvious red flags in a will, including language barriers, heir issues, and irregular execution. Heirs who suspect that a will was procured through fraud, falsity, or irregular notarization are not limited to fighting the probate case alone. When the judgeโ€™s handling of the estate proceeding shows inexcusable […]

When Lifetime Transfers Stay Out of the Estate Inventory: Lessons for Estate Tax and Probate Disputes

Lifetime-transferred property may be excluded from an estate inventory unless heirs timely prove collation, simulation, or ownership defects. Property transferred by a decedent during his lifetime does not automatically return to the estate inventory merely because heirs suspect that the transfer was really a disguised donation or an advance on inheritance. For families, executors, and […]

When a Notarized Will Is Hard to Defeat: The Probate Rule Every Heir Should Know

A notarized will supported by competent instrumental witnesses is difficult to defeat without clear, convincing proof of defective execution or incapacity. A notarized will supported by the testimony of its instrumental witnesses is not easily defeated by suspicion, family conflict, or minor inconsistencies. For heirs contesting a will, Gonzales v. Court of Appeals teaches a […]

Separate Estate, Separate Tax Life: Why Probate Accounting Can Keep an Inheritance Claim Alive

Separate estate tax returns and probate accounts helped prove that a wifeโ€™s estate survived and could not be treated as fully absorbed by her husbandโ€™s estate. Estate administrators cannot erase a surviving spouseโ€™s separate estate merely by treating all properties as one pool, especially when the record shows separate accounting, separate tax reporting, and a […]