COMELEC Cannot Cancel a Candidacy Through Generalized Nuisance-Candidate Labels

COMELEC must give specific factual and legal reasons before cancelling a candidacy as nuisance; generalized labels violate due process. Candidates who are branded as nuisance candidates must be told exactly what they did, what evidence proves it, and why those facts legally justify cancellation of their certificate of candidacy. The ruling in Diaz makes clear […]

COMELEC Plebiscite Deference: When Courts Will Uphold Election Results

COMELEC plebiscite results stand absent grave abuse; fraud claims require the proper remedy and convincing evidence. COMELEC plebiscite decisions will not be overturned merely because voters, local officials, or losing advocates allege confusion, irregularities, or disappointing turnout. Under the COMELEC Plebiscite Deference Doctrine, the Supreme Court will generally respect the Commission on Elections’ administration of […]

Dual Citizenship Residency Rule: Reacquired Filipinos Must Prove Domicile

Reacquiring Philippine citizenship does not restore local domicile; local candidates must prove one-year residence or risk COC cancellation for false claims. The Dual Citizenship Residency Rule means that reacquiring Philippine citizenship is not enough to run for local office: a returning Filipino must still prove legal residence, or domicile, in the locality for at least […]

Courts Will Not Decide an Election Protest After the Term Has Expired

Election protest cases may be dismissed as moot once the contested term expires and a new election is held, even if serious legal issues remain. Election protest cases can become legally useless once the disputed term of office has ended. Even if the legal questions are serious, and even if one side believes the recount […]