Retired Judges Can Still Be Fined for Undecided Cases Left Behind

A retired judge was fined for leaving 62 cases undecided, confirming that court delay may be gross neglect and retirement does not defeat prior discipline. Retirement does not erase judicial accountability when disciplinary proceedings began while the judge was still in office. A judge who leaves unresolved cases beyond the constitutional period may still be […]

Judges Are Not Liable for Every Wrong Order: Supreme Court Reaffirms Good Faith Protection in Judicial Decisions

The Supreme Court held that judicial error alone is not misconduct; parties must use appeals or certiorari unless fraud, bad faith, or corruption is proven. A judge’s mistaken ruling is not automatically judicial misconduct. Parties who believe a court order is wrong must ordinarily challenge it through appeal, certiorari, or other judicial remedies—not by turning […]

When Court Delay Becomes Judicial Misconduct: The Three-Month Decision Rule for Pending Cases

Trial judges must decide submitted cases within three months; missing transcripts, transferred staff, and workload do not excuse unreasonable delay. Parties who submit a case for decision are not expected to wait indefinitely: trial judges must decide lower court cases within the constitutional three-month period, and delay may result in administrative liability even when the […]

A Judge’s Silence Can Cost Him the Bench: Why Affidavits of Desistance Do Not Stop Judicial Discipline

The Supreme Court held that a judge may still be dismissed for gross misconduct despite a complainant’s affidavit of desistance or loss of interest. Judges and court personnel cannot make an administrative case disappear simply because the complainant later withdraws, signs an affidavit of desistance, or stops cooperating. When the alleged misconduct affects public trust […]

When Judges Attack the Court: Why Temperate Language Is Part of Judicial Discipline

Judges may defend themselves, but abusive language against the Supreme Court can amount to misconduct. The Court fined Judge Tamin for intemperate pleadings. Judges may criticize rulings and defend themselves in administrative proceedings, but they may not use vulgar, vindictive, or contemptuous language against the Supreme Court without facing discipline. The doctrine is simple but […]

Judges Who Abuse Case Parties Can Be Declared Unfit for Office Even After Dismissal

A judge may be held administratively liable for exploiting a litigant’s pending case through improper personal conduct, even if prior dismissal makes the penalty moot. Judicial office does not shield a judge from administrative accountability when the alleged misconduct occurs in a private setting but involves a party whose case is pending before him. A […]

Judges Are Not Disciplined on Suspicion Alone: Proof Still Matters in Court Misconduct Complaints

The Court dismissed a judicial misconduct complaint, holding that suspected conflict and docket delay do not prove liability without evidence, not suspicion alone. Administrative complaints against judges require evidence, not suspicion. A judge is not automatically liable for judicial misconduct merely because a spouse-lawyer has cases in the same court, or because the court’s docket […]