When a Criminal Conviction Fails Because Doubt Remains: The Payopay Rule on Testimony, Medical Evidence, and Uncharged Offenses

The Supreme Court reversed a rape conviction where testimony, medical evidence, and charging defects left reasonable doubt and barred conviction for an uncharged offense. A criminal conviction cannot rest on sympathy, suspicion, or even a plausible accusation when material gaps in the prosecutionโ€™s story leave reasonable doubt. Payopay is a reminder that the testimony of […]

A Rape Conviction Can Stand Despite Recantation, But Death Penalty Requires Strict Proof

Rape conviction affirmed despite recantation, but death penalty reduced because minority and stepfather relationship were not proven beyond reasonable doubt. Victims and accused persons alike should understand two hard rules from this ruling: a later denial or recantation will not automatically erase sworn testimony that the trial court found credible, but any circumstance that increases […]