Pleadings Scope Doctrine: Relief Limited to Filed Claims in Property Disputes

The Supreme Court affirmed that reliefs must be consistent with pleadings; parties cannot claim refunds or enforce agreements without properly filed claims. In Philippine civil litigation, parties are entitled only to reliefs consistent with the claims and issues formally presented in their pleadings. The Supreme Court has clarified that courts cannot grant judgments beyond what […]

Deed of Absolute Sale Doctrine: SC Clarifies Contract Validity and Performance

SC clarifies that deeds of absolute sale via Special Power of Attorney are enforceable only if conditions are ratified and incorporated, affecting property ownership rights. Property owners and buyers must now understand that a deed of absolute sale, even when executed through a Special Power of Attorney, is not automatically enforceable unless all conditions and […]

VAT Exemption Limits: Supreme Court Clarifies Input Tax Refunds

Supreme Court rules non-VAT SBFZ enterprises cannot claim input VAT refunds; only VAT-registered taxpayers may recover erroneously charged VAT. Businesses operating in special economic zones cannot claim refunds for input VAT on purchases if they are not VAT-registered, even when suppliers erroneously pass on VAT. This ruling underscores the strict legal distinction between VAT liability […]

COA Audit Jurisdiction Doctrine: Limits on Charging LWDs Fees

The SC ruled LWDs are government-owned and subject to COA audits; attempts to classify them as private to evade fees are invalid. Government entities must now recognize that local water districts (LWDs) are not private corporations and remain subject to audit by the Commission on Audit (COA). This ruling clarifies that attempts to exempt LWDs […]