Taxpayers Cannot Immediately Appeal Procedural Setbacks in Pending Court of Tax Appeals Cases

CTA En Banc dismissed a taxpayer’s appeal from a procedural ruling, holding that interlocutory orders in pending tax assessment cases are not immediately appealable. Taxpayers challenging a tax assessment before the Court of Tax Appeals must be careful not to treat every adverse procedural ruling as immediately appealable. When a case is still pending before […]

BIR Appeals Can Fail Without OSG Authority in Tax Assessment Cases

A BIR assessment appeal was dismissed after the Commissioner failed to prove OSG authority for BIR counsel, reinforcing strict procedural compliance in CTA cases. Taxpayers facing a government appeal in a tax assessment case should scrutinize not only the alleged tax liability, but also whether the government’s petition was filed by lawyers with proper authority. […]

Late BIR Appeals Can End Tax Assessment Cases Before the Merits Are Reached

The CTA dismissed the Commissioner’s late appeal, holding that service on the OSG controlled the deadline and deprived the Court of jurisdiction. Taxpayers who win before a Division of the Court of Tax Appeals may secure finality when the government misses the strict appeal deadline, even where the Bureau of Internal Revenue received the court […]

Willful Failure to Pay Tax Cases Require Proof of Both Notice and Tax Liability

Criminal tax prosecution for willful failure to pay tax failed after the court found insufficient proof of all elements and civil tax liability. Taxpayers facing criminal prosecution for alleged willful failure to pay tax cannot be convicted on assumptions about receipt of BIR notices, possession of documents, or unpaid liabilities; the prosecution must still prove […]

RR No. 33-2020: Extended 2018 VAPP Availment and Expanded No-Audit Protection for Qualified Taxpayers

RR No. 33-2020 extends 2018 VAPP availment to June 30, 2021 and clarifies no-audit protection, audit suspension, invalidation grounds, and appeal rights. Taxpayers seeking to close 2018 tax exposure under the Voluntary Assessment and Payment Program received more time and clearer procedural protection: qualified persons may avail of the VAPP benefits until June 30, 2021, […]

RMC No. 22-2012: Pre-1998 BIR Rulings Cannot Be Used as Precedent for Current Tax Positions and New Ruling Requests

RMC No. 22-2012 bars taxpayers from using pre-1998 BIR rulings as precedent for current transactions, ruling requests, or assessment defenses. Taxpayers relying on old BIR rulings issued before January 1, 1998 must reassess their tax positions immediately: RMC No. 22-2012 clarifies that those rulings cannot be cited as precedent for current business transactions, new ruling […]

Gross Receipts Means Gross: Banks Cannot Reduce Tax Base by Final Withholding Tax

Banks cannot deduct final withholding tax from gross receipts tax. The Court treated withheld passive income as constructively received and taxable. Banks and financial institutions cannot reduce their gross receipts tax base by subtracting the final withholding tax already withheld on passive income. For tax purposes, gross receipts means the whole amount received or constructively […]

Stock Dividends With Par Value Are Taxed on Par Value, Not Book Value

Stock dividends with par value are subject to documentary stamp tax based on par value, not book value, limiting BIR deficiency assessments. Corporations issuing stock dividends with par value cannot be assessed documentary stamp tax based on the higher book value of those shares when the stock certificates themselves state a par value. For companies […]