BIR Cannot Revive a Dismissed Criminal Tax Case Without Proper OSG Authority

Tax authority’s certiorari petition was dismissed after a criminal tax case demurrer due to lack of proper OSG authority and mere evidentiary review. Government tax prosecutors cannot treat every adverse ruling in a criminal tax case as a certiorari issue. When a trial court grants a demurrer to evidence and dismisses a criminal tax prosecution, […]

Late Tax Court Filings Can Defeat Mandamus Relief Before Merits Are Heard

A taxpayer’s mandamus plea in a BIR assessment dispute failed because the late filing left the tax court without jurisdiction, making merits arguments immaterial. Taxpayers seeking mandamus relief in a tax assessment dispute must treat the filing deadline as a jurisdictional threshold, not a procedural detail that can be cured by arguing the merits later. […]

Petitions for Relief in Tax Cases Must Be Filed in the Same Case, Not as a New Action

A tax court resolution reminds taxpayers that petitions for relief from judgment must be filed in the same tax case, not as a new action. Taxpayers and government litigants seeking to reopen a final tax judgment must file the petition for relief in the same case where the judgment, order, or proceeding was entered. A […]

Taxpayers Cannot Extend the 30-Day Deadline to Appeal a BIR Assessment to the Tax Court

Taxpayers must appeal an FDDA within 30 days; a motion for extension may not preserve the right to challenge a BIR assessment before the tax court. Taxpayers who receive a Final Decision on Disputed Assessment must be ready to file their Petition for Review within 30 days, because asking for extra time may not protect […]

When a Tax Case Can Be Won or Lost Before Trial

Early procedural choices can decide tax litigation before trial, from motions to dismiss and prescription defenses to default, discovery, and pleading strategy. Tax disputes can be decided long before witnesses are presented: a taxpayer, collecting officer, corporation, or government agency may win or lose the case at the pleading stage if the complaint, answer, discovery […]

Void BIR Assessments Cannot Become Final Despite Protest Defects

A void BIR assessment for denial of due process cannot become final merely because of protest defects, preserving taxpayer defenses in assessment disputes. Taxpayers facing deficiency tax assessments should not assume that a missed or defective protest automatically ends the case when the assessment itself is void for denial of due process. The ruling is […]

RMC No. 25-2010: BIR and OSG Tax Litigation Coordination Rules for Appeals and Supreme Court Cases

RMC No. 25-2010 clarifies BIR and OSG roles in tax litigation, appeals, Supreme Court cases, case turnover, and enforcement of favorable tax rulings. Tax cases involving the BIR now follow a clearer division of responsibility between BIR handling lawyers and the Office of the Solicitor General, especially when cases move from trial-level proceedings to appellate […]

RMO No. 15-2010: BIR Court Case Handling Rules Require On-Time Hearings, Timely Reports, and Action on Adverse Tax Decisions

RMO No. 15-2010 tightened BIR court case handling through on-time hearings, reporting deadlines, quality pleadings, and action on adverse tax rulings. Taxpayers with pending BIR court cases should expect tighter government litigation management, closer monitoring of hearings, fewer postponements, and faster internal action on adverse rulings. RMO No. 15-2010 took effect immediately on February 4, […]

When a Tax Prescription Loss Becomes a Collectible Deficiency: The Sison Finality Rule

A taxpayer who loses a prescription defense may face enforceable tax collection when the final judgment sustains the assessment and fixes liability. Taxpayers who lose a prescription defense in a tax case may not automatically get a second opportunity to relitigate the merits of the assessment. Where the court’s prior judgment necessarily sustains the tax […]