Tax Courts Cannot Rewrite Tax Policy: Why Jewelry Taxes Survived a Constitutional Challenge

The Supreme Court held that courts cannot invalidate jewelry taxes merely because they seem harsh or unwise; tax policy belongs to Congress. Businesses cannot defeat a tax law merely by showing that it is harsh, commercially inconvenient, or less competitive than tax policies in other countries. The controlling doctrine from this ruling is simple but […]

Habeas Corpus Still Matters When Customs Enforcement Leads to Detention Without Charges

Habeas corpus may challenge detention without charges, but release or court commitment can moot the remedy while leaving officials exposed to scrutiny. People detained in customs, smuggling, or tax-enforcement investigations may use habeas corpus to force the government to justify the restraint, but the remedy can become moot once the person is released or placed […]

When New Procedural Rules Overtake a Pending Criminal Challenge

A procedural attack on preliminary investigation may fail when later legal changes validate the challenged prosecutor authority and procedure. People challenging a prosecutor’s authority in a pending criminal matter can lose the case when the very procedure they attack is later adopted as part of controlling law. In Litton v. Castillo, the Supreme Court treated […]