Unauthorized BIR Audits Can Defeat Tax Collection and Criminal Tax Charges

A void BIR audit can invalidate deficiency tax assessments, defeating collection and civil liability despite arguments that the FAN became final. Taxpayers facing criminal tax cases or collection efforts should closely examine whether the BIR officers who conducted the audit were properly authorized, because a void examination can invalidate the resulting deficiency tax assessment and […]

Government Tax Prosecutions Face a Jurisdiction Trap After Demurrer-Based Acquittals

The tax court dismissed the government’s Rule 65 challenge for lack of jurisdiction after a demurrer-based acquittal in a criminal tax case. Taxpayers facing criminal tax cases before the Court of Tax Appeals gain a significant procedural advantage when the prosecution loses on demurrer to evidence: the government may still attempt a Rule 65 challenge, […]

Tax Assessment Appeal Separation: CTA Remedies in Tax Evasion Cases

A tax evasion case does not automatically preserve a taxpayer’s CTA appeal from a BIR assessment; the FDDA must be separately challenged. Taxpayers facing both a tax evasion case and a disputed assessment must treat the assessment appeal as a separate CTA remedy. The Tax Assessment Appeal Separation Doctrine means that a criminal tax case […]