Illegal Cigarette Excise Tax Case Fails After Invalid Vehicle Search

A cigarette excise tax prosecution failed after the Court excluded seized goods from an invalid vehicle search, defeating both conviction and civil tax liability. Tax enforcement cases involving cigarettes, fuel, alcohol, and other excisable goods can collapse if the government’s evidence is obtained through an unconstitutional search. For taxpayers, importers, logistics providers, truckers, and drivers, […]

Late Certiorari Filing Ends Government Challenge in Criminal Tax Prosecution

Late certiorari filing barred review of a criminal tax case after the public prosecutor’s receipt controlled the deadline and the RTC orders became final. Government prosecutors in criminal tax cases must track reglementary periods from the proper prosecuting authority’s receipt of court orders, not merely from the later receipt by deputized tax lawyers, because a […]

Taxpayers Can Face Civil Tax Liability Even Without a Formal BIR Assessment

Taxpayers in criminal tax cases may still face civil liability for unpaid taxes even without a formal BIR assessment, if competent evidence supports the amount due. Taxpayers facing criminal tax cases cannot assume that the absence of a formal BIR assessment will defeat civil liability for unpaid taxes. In a March 2026 resolution, the tax […]

When a Criminal Case Cannot Be Stopped Mid-Trial: The Joseph Doctrine on Demurrers, Certiorari, and Separate Trials

A denied mid-trial motion to acquit usually cannot stop a criminal case by certiorari, but separate trials may be ordered to prevent prejudice among accused. Accused persons, including taxpayers and corporate officers facing criminal prosecution, cannot usually stop a criminal case through certiorari simply because they believe the prosecution’s evidence is weak. The remedy is […]