Tax Evasion Charges Can Fail Before Trial When the Information Is Defective

A criminal tax case was dismissed after prosecutors failed to correct defects in the Information, highlighting key defenses in tax evasion prosecutions. Prosecutors pursuing criminal tax cases must ensure that the Information is complete, accurate, and supported by required attachments, because unresolved pleading defects may result in dismissal before the accused is ever required to […]

When a Tax Evasion Case Is Dismissed, the Supreme Court Will Not Decide Moot Procedural Battles

Supreme Court held that a dismissed tax evasion case moots pending procedural challenges unless a recognized exception to mootness applies. A taxpayer or corporate officer who already obtained a final dismissal of a tax evasion case generally cannot still ask the Supreme Court to rule on earlier procedural objections in that same criminal case. The […]

Tax Evasion Case Dismissed After Late Filing: What Prescription Means for BIR Criminal Prosecutions

A criminal tax case was dismissed after the Information was filed beyond the five-year prescriptive period for Tax Code violations. Taxpayers facing criminal tax charges should closely examine when the government discovered and pursued the alleged offense, because a prosecution filed beyond the five-year prescriptive period may be dismissed before trial. For corporations and responsible […]

BIR Cannot Revive a Dismissed Criminal Tax Case Without Proper OSG Authority

Tax authority’s certiorari petition was dismissed after a criminal tax case demurrer due to lack of proper OSG authority and mere evidentiary review. Government tax prosecutors cannot treat every adverse ruling in a criminal tax case as a certiorari issue. When a trial court grants a demurrer to evidence and dismisses a criminal tax prosecution, […]

PDR Tax Prosecution Fails Without Proof of Dealer Status or Taxable Gain

PDR tax prosecution failed after the court found no dealer activity, taxable gain, VAT liability, or civil tax liability from the disputed transactions. Tax prosecutions arising from alleged unreported Philippine Depositary Receipt transactions cannot succeed unless the government first proves the basic tax premise: that the taxpayer was actually acting as a dealer in securities, […]

Tax Exemption Proof Rule: When Unsupported Tax-Free Claims Fail

Tax-free import claims must be clearly proven; unsupported exemption claims may allow BIR tax evasion and perjury charges to proceed. Taxpayers who claim that large transactions are tax-free must be ready to prove it with clear documents, because an unsupported claim of exemption may not stop a criminal tax case from proceeding. The Tax Exemption […]

Tax Evasion by Expenditure Method: When Wealth Triggers Prosecution

Unexplained wealth may justify tax evasion charges even without a prior assessment if the BIR shows probable cause that tax is due. Taxpayers whose major cash purchases grossly exceed their declared income may face criminal prosecution for tax evasion even without a prior deficiency assessment. The doctrine is the tax evasion by expenditure method rule: […]

Tax Evasion Begins When the False Return Is Filed: Why Later Payments May Not Stop Prosecution

Tax evasion may be prosecuted once a fraudulent return is filed; later payments, VAP claims, or audit immunity may not bar criminal charges. A taxpayer accused of filing fraudulent returns cannot automatically avoid criminal prosecution by pointing to later tax payments, audit immunity certificates, or settlement programs. The Supreme Court held that tax evasion is […]

Tax Evasion Completion Rule: Fraudulent Returns Can Trigger Prosecution

Fraudulent tax returns can trigger prosecution; audit immunity and late assessment objections will not automatically defeat tax evasion charges. The Tax Evasion Completion Rule means a taxpayer cannot avoid criminal exposure merely by attacking audit technicalities, invoking audit immunity, or arguing that the assessment process was imperfect. Once a fraudulent return is knowingly and willfully […]