When a Tax Evasion Case Is Dismissed, the Supreme Court Will Not Decide Moot Procedural Battles

Supreme Court held that a dismissed tax evasion case moots pending procedural challenges unless a recognized exception to mootness applies. A taxpayer or corporate officer who already obtained a final dismissal of a tax evasion case generally cannot still ask the Supreme Court to rule on earlier procedural objections in that same criminal case. The […]

Acquittal Ends the Case: Why the State Cannot Keep Fighting After a Plunder Defendant Is Cleared

Acquittal ends related criminal petitions: the Supreme Court held that final acquittal bars further review that would reopen liability or evidence. An acquitted accused gains an immediate right of repose: once a competent court clears the accused after trial, the State generally cannot keep litigating related issues that would reopen the criminal controversy, revisit the […]

Tax Evasion Cases Can Proceed Even Without a Formal BIR Assessment

Fraudulent tax return cases may proceed without a formal BIR assessment; a DOJ referral is not an appealable tax assessment before the CTA. Taxpayers suspected of filing fraudulent tax returns cannot stop a tax evasion case simply by arguing that the Bureau of Internal Revenue has not yet issued a formal assessment. When the alleged […]

Handwriting Evidence Alone Cannot Convict Public Officers for Treasury Fraud

Handwriting suspicion alone cannot convict a public officer for treasury fraud when proof of participation, conspiracy, and guilt beyond reasonable doubt is lacking. Public officers accused of falsification, estafa, or fraud involving government funds cannot be convicted on the strength of handwriting opinion alone when the prosecution fails to prove participation, conspiracy, and guilt beyond […]