Customs Criminal Cases Can Collapse When the Prosecution Fails to Prove Probable Cause

A customs criminal case was dismissed without prejudice after the prosecution failed to submit required annexes, leaving insufficient proof of probable cause. Importers, traders, brokers, and business owners facing customs-related criminal charges should closely examine whether the prosecution has actually placed the necessary supporting documents on record, because a customs violation case may be dismissed […]

VAT Refund Denied for Failure to Prove Zero-Rated Sales Through Proper Official Receipts

VAT refund denied despite timely filing because zero-rated service receipts failed strict substantiation and invoicing rules under the Tax Code. Businesses claiming VAT refunds for zero-rated services must be able to prove, through properly issued and BIR-registered official receipts, not only that payments were received, but also the exact nature of the services covered by […]

BIR Collection by Distraint and Levy Fails When a Tax Protest Is Still Validly Pending

The tax court cancelled a P325.6M BIR assessment and distraint warrant after finding a valid pending protest and due process violations. Taxpayers facing a warrant of distraint and levy may still challenge collection when the underlying assessment is under a valid protest or when the BIR failed to address the taxpayerโ€™s defenses before issuing the […]

VAT Refund Appeals Can Be Lost When the Taxpayer Ignores a BIR Denial Letter

A VAT refund appeal was dismissed because the 30-day period ran from the taxpayerโ€™s receipt of the BIR denial letter, not counselโ€™s receipt, making deadline controls critical. Taxpayers claiming VAT refunds or tax credits must treat a BIR denial letter served directly on the company as immediately binding for appeal-period purposes, even if the company […]

PDR Tax Prosecution Fails Without Proof of Dealer Status or Taxable Gain

PDR tax prosecution failed after the court found no dealer activity, taxable gain, VAT liability, or civil tax liability from the disputed transactions. Tax prosecutions arising from alleged unreported Philippine Depositary Receipt transactions cannot succeed unless the government first proves the basic tax premise: that the taxpayer was actually acting as a dealer in securities, […]

Wrong Zonal Value Can Support a Capital Gains Tax Refund, Tax Court Says

Tax court granted a capital gains tax refund after finding the BIR used the wrong zonal value and improperly imposed surcharge and excess interest. Real property sellers who paid capital gains tax based on an overstated zonal value may recover the excess tax, surcharge, and interest if they can prove the correct valuation through competent […]

Late Government Appeals Can End Tax Crime Cases Before the Merits Are Heard

A criminal tax appeal was dismissed after the government missed the deadline, making DOJ receipt controlling over later BIR receipt in tax prosecutions. A tax prosecution can collapse before the appellate court ever reaches the alleged tax violation when the government misses the deadline to seek further review. For taxpayers, corporate officers, and defense counsel […]

Late Government Motions Can End Criminal Tax Cases Before Trial

The Court affirmed dismissal of a criminal tax case, underscoring prescription, strict motion deadlines, and procedural defenses in BIR prosecutions. Taxpayers facing criminal tax charges should not assume that a government appeal or reconsideration will automatically revive a dismissed case. Where the prosecution misses mandatory procedural deadlines, the dismissal of a tax criminal case may […]

BIR Tax Assessments Can Be Voided When Substitute Revenue Officers Lack a Valid LOA

Tax court denied the BIRโ€™s reconsideration and kept a โ‚ฑ1.307B assessment void because substitute audit officers lacked a valid new or amended LOA. Taxpayers facing BIR deficiency tax assessments should closely check whether the revenue officers who actually continued the audit were expressly named in a valid Letter of Authority. In this February 2025 resolution, […]

BIR Assessments May Be Voided When Taxpayers Are Denied the Full 15 Days to Answer a PAN

Premature issuance of a Formal Assessment Notice before the 15-day PAN reply period expired voided a Php308.8M BIR tax assessment. Taxpayers who receive a Preliminary Assessment Notice must be given the full fifteen days allowed by the BIRโ€™s own rules to respond before a Formal Assessment Notice is issued; otherwise, the resulting deficiency tax assessment […]