Excise Tax Refunds for PEZA Sales: Tax Court Orders BIR to Return Imported Fuel Taxes

Tax court partially granted a P134.94M excise tax refund for imported bunker fuel sold to a PEZA entity, stressing proof and PEZA documentation. Importers that pay excise tax on petroleum products may still recover those taxes when the products are later sold and delivered to a qualified tax-exempt buyer, but only if the sale, delivery, […]

Missed Electronic Filing Rules Can End a Tax Certiorari Case Before It Begins

A tax certiorari petition was dismissed after the petitioner failed to submit the required soft copy within 24 hours of hard-copy filing. Taxpayers and individuals challenging tax-related criminal proceedings before the Court of Tax Appeals must treat electronic filing requirements as jurisdictionally serious compliance obligations because a petition may be deemed not filed, and the […]

Late Motions Can End Tax Collection Challenges Before the Merits Are Heard

A taxpayer’s CTA challenge to BIR levy measures failed after its motion for reconsideration was filed six days late, making the dismissal final. Taxpayers challenging BIR collection measures must treat Court of Tax Appeals deadlines as jurisdictional, because even a potentially serious objection to a levy, warrant, or collection action may be lost if a […]

Tax Appeals Can Be Lost on Filing Deadlines Even Before the Merits Are Heard

A tax assessment appeal was dismissed after the taxpayer failed to overcome receipt and filing deadline issues before the Court of Tax Appeals. Taxpayers challenging a BIR final decision must treat the appeal period as a jurisdictional deadline, not a procedural formality. If the Court of Tax Appeals finds that the petition for review was […]

Tax Refund Claim Denied After Taxpayer Tried to Reopen Evidence on Alleged Double FWT Payment

The CTA denied reconsideration and refused to reopen a final withholding tax refund case because the taxpayer’s added proof was forgotten, not newly discovered, evidence. Taxpayers claiming a refund or tax credit for allegedly overpaid withholding taxes must prove the overpayment with complete, competent, and timely presented evidence during trial; they cannot wait for an […]

BIR Cannot Reopen a Settled Audit Through a New LOA for the Same Taxable Period

A taxpayer defeated a P41.3M BIR assessment after the tax court voided a repeated audit, unauthorized officer action, prescription, and defective demand. Taxpayers who have already gone through a completed BIR audit, received final decisions, and paid the assessed amounts may challenge a later attempt to revive the same issue through another Letter of Authority, […]

VAT Refund Appeals Can Be Lost on Filing Proof, Not Just Tax Merits

VAT refund appeal dismissed after late MR; Court En Banc stressed strict proof of filing and jurisdictional deadlines in tax credit cases. Taxpayers pursuing VAT refund or tax credit claims must treat procedural filing rules as strictly as the substantiation requirements for the refund itself, because a missed or poorly documented motion for reconsideration can […]

BIR Collection Warrants Can Be Voided When Issued After the Prescriptive Period

CTA voided BIR collection for old income tax and VAT assessments after finding the warrant was issued beyond the extended collection deadline. Taxpayers facing old deficiency tax assessments may defeat collection if the Bureau of Internal Revenue allows the collection period to lapse, even where the assessment itself was timely issued under the ten-year rule […]

Late Appeals Can End Criminal Tax Cases Before the Merits Are Heard

A criminal tax appeal was dismissed as late because the 15-day period ran from DOJ receipt, not BIR receipt, leaving the CTA En Banc without jurisdiction. Government prosecutors, BIR officers, and accused taxpayers in criminal tax cases must treat appeal deadlines as jurisdictional: once the 15-day period is missed, the Court of Tax Appeals En […]

Premature Tax Assessments Can Be Voided When the BIR Issues the Final Demand Too Soon

Premature issuance of a Final Letter of Demand before the taxpayer’s 15-day PAN response period lapsed rendered the tax assessment void. Taxpayers who receive a Preliminary Assessment Notice must be given the full 15-day period to respond before the BIR issues a Final Letter of Demand and Final Assessment Notice. When the BIR proceeds too […]