Tax Appeals Can Be Lost Before the Merits If Filing Rules Are Not Strictly Followed

A tax assessment appeal was dismissed for improper electronic filing and lack of certification against forum shopping, showing strict CTA procedure can decide cases. Taxpayers, importers, customs brokers, and even the Commissioner can lose a tax appeal before any deficiency assessment issue is reviewed when the petition is filed through the wrong mode or lacks […]

BIR Cannot Collect a New Income Tax Assessment First Raised in the Final Demand

A new income tax assessment first raised in the FLD/FAN was void for violating due process, and the taxpayerโ€™s mailed protest was timely. Taxpayers facing a BIR assessment should check whether the exact tax issue being collected was disclosed early enough in the audit process. A deficiency tax item that appears for the first time […]

Yearbook Printing Can Be VAT-Exempt: Tax Court Cancels Deficiency VAT and Income Tax Assessment

Tax court cancels deficiency VAT and income tax assessments, holding that printed yearbooks qualify as VAT-exempt books and BIR rulings cannot apply retroactively. Printers, publishers, schools, and student organizations should not assume that yearbook printing is automatically subject to VAT merely because a later BIR ruling says so. In this decision, the tax court cancelled […]

VAT Refund Claims Cannot Be Denied Solely for Lack of Prior Zero-Rating Approval

A VAT refund claim may not be denied solely for lack of prior BIR zero-rating approval where the taxpayer proves the legal and factual basis for zero-rated sales. VAT-registered suppliers claiming refunds or tax credit certificates for input VAT attributable to zero-rated sales should not lose their claim merely because they did not secure a […]

Taxpayers Who Pay a Disputed BIR Assessment May Still Control the Timing of Case Dismissal

Taxpayer paid the disputed 2017 deficiency taxes and filed a timely notice of dismissal before answer, leading the CTA to close the assessment case. Taxpayers who decide to settle or pay a disputed BIR assessment while a Court of Tax Appeals case is pending should act promptly to control the procedural consequences of dismissal. In […]

Missed Tax Protest Deadlines Can End a Taxpayerโ€™s CTA Appeal Before the Merits Are Heard

A taxpayer lost its CTA assessment appeal after failing to prove timely reconsideration of an FDDA, making the deficiency tax assessment final and demandable. Taxpayers challenging deficiency tax assessments must treat every receipt date as jurisdictional evidence, because an untimely administrative appeal can make an assessment final, executory, and demandable before the Court of Tax […]

BIR Assessments Are Void When Replacement Revenue Officers Audit Without a New LOA

BIR assessments may be void when replacement revenue officers continue an audit without a new LOA, even if a memorandum of assignment was issued. Taxpayers facing deficiency income tax, withholding tax, VAT, and compromise penalty assessments should closely verify whether the revenue officers who actually conducted the audit were named in a valid Letter of […]

Taxpayers Can Lose Warrant Challenges by Filing Petitions Through Licensed Courier

A taxpayerโ€™s warrant challenge was dismissed after a petition sent by licensed courier was received late, leaving the VAT assessment issues unresolved. Taxpayers challenging a warrant of distraint and/or levy or a warrant of garnishment must treat the 30-day Court of Tax Appeals filing period as jurisdictional and must file the petition using an allowed […]

Tax Assessments Can Be Voided When the BIR Fails to Explain Its Decision in Writing

Taxpayers may challenge BIR assessments when the Commissioner denies a protest without explaining in writing why the taxpayer’s arguments were rejected. Taxpayers who file a protest against a BIR assessment must receive more than a bare rejection of their position. Where the Commissioner fails to explain in writing why the taxpayer’s factual and legal arguments […]