Corporate Appeals Can Fail When the Wrong Person Signs for the Company

A corporate appeal may fail if filed without valid authority or a proper anti-forum shopping certification, even before courts reach the merits. A corporation, association, or business organization can lose an appeal before the Supreme Court without any review of the merits if the petition is filed by persons who lack authority to act for […]

Corporate Petitions Can Fail on Paperwork: Why Board Authority Matters Before Filing in Court

Corporations may lose court remedies when officers sign litigation certifications without board authority, even before merits are heard. Corporations that go to court through an officer must be ready to prove that the officer was specifically authorized to act for the company, especially when signing a certification against forum shopping. A case may be lost […]

When a Main Case Is Withdrawn, a Counterclaim May Fall With It

A counterclaim may fall when the main civil case is dismissed, and jurisdictional objections not raised below may be barred on appeal. A litigant who agrees to the dismissal of the main civil case cannot usually keep only the counterclaim alive as if it were an independent lawsuit. The practical lesson is simple but often […]

Late Appeal Records Should Not Automatically Kill a Meritorious Case

A late appeal record should not automatically defeat review when delay is slight, explained, and causes no substantial prejudice to the opposing party. Courts should not dismiss an appeal merely because a required appeal record was filed late when the delay is slight, the appellant did not intend to abandon the case, and no substantial […]

Final Judgments Can Kill an Appeal Even After a Temporary Restraining Order

A temporary restraining order cannot save an appeal once the underlying judgment becomes final and no grave reversible error is shown. A party who obtains temporary relief from an appellate court can still lose the case if the underlying judgment becomes final and executory. The controlling lesson is procedural but decisive: once the lower court […]

A Missed Brief Does Not Always Kill an Appeal on a Pure Question of Law

A timely appeal on a pure question of law may proceed despite procedural objections, especially where requiring certiorari would duplicate an appeal. A party who timely perfects an appeal on a pure question of law may still be allowed to proceed even if the record shows procedural imperfections, especially where requiring a separate certiorari petition […]