Protective Filing Is Not Always Forum Shopping: When Uncertain Venue Justifies Multiple Cases

The Supreme Court held that good-faith protective filings caused by venue uncertainty are not forum shopping when disclosed and promptly withdrawn. Parties facing a short filing deadline are not automatically guilty of forum shopping when they file protective cases in multiple courts to preserve their rights, disclose those filings, and promptly withdraw the cases once […]

When a Corporate Election Dispute Must Be Filed Within 15 Days

Corporate election challenges involving proxies, quorum, or board authority must be filed within 15 days, or courts may bar evidence on election validity. Corporate members who want to challenge the authority of elected directors cannot wait until a later disciplinary or governance dispute arises before attacking the election. If the complaint questions the validation of […]

Corporate Appeals Should Not Die on Missing Paperwork Alone

The Supreme Court held that a corporate petition should not be dismissed solely for a missing authority document when substantial compliance is later shown. A corporate appeal should not be defeated merely because the petition initially lacked a secretary’s certificate or board resolution, when the officer who signed was in a position to verify the […]

Certified True Copies in Certiorari Petitions: Why One Missing Stamp Should Not Defeat a Meritorious Appeal

Certiorari petitions need certified true copies of the assailed ruling, not every annex. Van Melle protects meritorious appeals from technical dismissal. Litigants challenging a court, tribunal, or agency ruling by certiorari do not need to secure certified true copies of every pleading and attachment in the record. What must be certified is the judgment, order, […]

When Contempt Becomes Personal: Why Judges Cannot Use Court Power to Punish Officials for Seeking Review

Judges may punish disobedience to court orders, but indirect contempt requires due process and restraint. Misuse of contempt power can trigger discipline. Court orders must be obeyed, but contempt power is not a judge’s private weapon. When a judge uses indirect contempt to punish government officials for pursuing available remedies, acting in apparent bad faith, […]

A Missed Proof of Service Can Suspend a Lawyer and Derail an Appeal

Lawyers handling appeals, tax controversies, and other deadline-driven proceedings can face suspension when they neglect even a procedural requirement that prevents the opposing side or the government from performing its own duty in court. The lesson is direct: a missed filing step is not always a harmless technicality. When it reflects neglect of a client’s […]

When a Finance Officer Receives Court Papers, the Corporation May Already Be in Court

Corporate summons served on a responsible finance and administrative officer may bind the company; technical defects will not always justify dismissal. A corporation cannot automatically defeat a lawsuit by arguing that court papers were handed to the wrong officer when the papers reached a responsible corporate functionary, counsel had notice, and the company appeared in […]

Missed Appeal Deadlines Can Kill a Tax Case: When Extensions Are Allowed and When They Are Not

Lacsamana explains when appeal extensions are allowed, warning taxpayers that the wrong appellate remedy or late filing can defeat even strong tax defenses. Taxpayers who lose before a court or quasi-judicial body cannot assume that asking for more time will preserve their appeal. Lacsamana clarified a hard procedural dividing line: some appeals allow extensions, but […]

When the First Court Gets the Case: Jurisdiction Lessons for Tax and Regulatory Prosecutions

A court that first validly acquires jurisdiction over a criminal case keeps it, even when co-accused face different penalties. A criminal prosecution should not be split between courts merely because different accused persons may face different penalties. When one court first validly acquires jurisdiction over the offense, that court proceeds with the case and excludes […]

Poor Litigants Can Appeal Without Paying for a Printed Record

Pauper litigants allowed to appeal need not file a printed record on appeal; procedural reforms may apply retroactively to protect appellate review. Litigants who are allowed to appeal as paupers are not required to shoulder the cost of preparing and filing a printed record on appeal. For taxpayers, property owners, and ordinary litigants who may […]