Criminal Tax Cases Can Still Be Dismissed When the Government Files Too Late

A criminal tax case remained dismissed after the Court held that a later DOJ tolling rule could not revive a prosecution already barred by prescription. Taxpayers and corporate officers facing criminal tax charges may still invoke prescription when the government files the Information in court after the five-year period, especially where applying a later Supreme […]

Late Criminal Tax Cases Can Be Dismissed When the Five-Year Prescription Period Has Already Run

A criminal tax case was dismissed after the Court found the five-year prescription period had run before the Information was filed. Taxpayers facing criminal tax charges may invoke prescription where the government files the Information in the Court of Tax Appeals beyond the five-year period under the Tax Code, especially when the alleged failure to […]

PAGCOR Licensees Can Defeat DST Assessments, But Not Withholding VAT on Foreign Suppliers

PAGCOR bingo licensee defeated DST and compromise penalties, but the Court upheld final withholding VAT on payments to a foreign supplier. PAGCOR-licensed gaming operators should not assume that the 5% franchise tax shields every tax exposure connected to their operations. For bingo and similar gaming businesses, the ruling confirms a critical distinction: documentary stamp tax […]

A Void Tax Audit Cannot Be Revived by Delay: Supreme Court Shields Taxpayers from Unauthorized BIR Examiners and Stale Collection Demands

Supreme Court voids a DST assessment for lack of proper LOA and prescription, protecting taxpayers from unauthorized BIR audits and stale collection demands. Taxpayers may defeat a BIR assessment when the revenue officers who conducted the audit were not specifically named in a valid Letter of Authority, and even a formally issued assessment cannot be […]

Tax Fraud Cannot Be Presumed: Why Vague BIR Assessments Can Be Voided

Supreme Court voided BIR deficiency assessments where fraud, taxable income, and the factual basis for extending prescription were not clearly proven. Taxpayers facing old deficiency tax assessments can defeat them when the BIR relies on suspicion, unexplained computations, or unproven allegations of fraud instead of clearly stated facts. The Supreme Court confirmed that the government […]

Tax Fraud Assessment Due Process: When BIR Assessments Become Void

BIR fraud assessments are void if taxpayers are not told the factual basis and fraud is not proven by clear and convincing evidence. Taxpayers facing fraud-based deficiency assessments may defeat a belated BIR claim when the assessment rests on assumptions, undisclosed evidence, or an unexplained attribution of income. The Tax Fraud Assessment Due Process Doctrine […]

LOA Revalidation Rule: When a BIR Audit Stands Despite Delay

A BIR audit LOA must be validly served, but a 120-day delay does not automatically void assessments absent proof of due process violation. The LOA Revalidation Rule protects taxpayers from unauthorized BIR audits, but it does not automatically erase a tax assessment every time an audit takes longer than 120 days. For businesses facing a […]

RMC No. 74-2020: BIR Limits Suspension of Tax Assessment and Collection Deadlines to ECQ Areas

RMC No. 74-2020 clarifies that BIR tax assessment and collection prescription is suspended from March 16, 2020 until ECQ lifting plus 60 days. Businesses and taxpayers in areas placed under enhanced community quarantine must account for a suspended BIR assessment and collection prescriptive period starting March 16, 2020 and continuing until the lifting of the […]

Substantial Justice in Tax Appeals: Technical Defects Should Not End Cases

Tax appeals should not be dismissed for curable defects when substantial justice requires a merits ruling in a major BIR assessment case. Substantial justice in tax appeals means that a multimillion-peso tax case should not be thrown out merely because a petition contains curable formal defects, especially where both sides have attempted to correct the […]

Tax Refunds Can Expire Even While the BIR Stays Silent

Final withholding tax refunds require both BIR and CTA filings within two years from payment; BIR inaction does not stop prescription. A taxpayer who asks the BIR for a refund cannot simply wait for the agency to act. When the two-year period is about to expire, the taxpayer must also file the case in the […]