Tax Refunds Cannot Be Defeated by Unappealed Deficiency Assessments Alone

A taxpayer’s proven income tax refund cannot be defeated by separate deficiency assessments unless the BIR proves them through proper evidence and procedure. A taxpayer who proves that an income tax refund is due cannot be denied that refund merely because the BIR points to separate deficiency tax assessments that were not properly appealed or […]

Foreign Contractors Cannot Stretch Tax Exemptions Beyond Clear Treaty Text

Foreign contractors cannot claim Philippine tax exemptions unless their income clearly falls within the exact legal text. Sea-Land’s refund was denied. Tax exemptions in the Philippines remain narrow privileges, not presumptions. A foreign company seeking a refund must show that its income falls squarely within the exact words of the exemption; relatedness to a government […]

When the BIR Keeps an Overpayment, It Cannot Charge Interest on the Same Money

A taxpayer overpayment already held by the government must reduce later deficiency interest; the BIR cannot charge interest on funds it should credit or refund. Taxpayers who overpay taxes by mistake are not automatically delinquent on the full amount of a later deficiency if the government was already holding money that rightfully belonged to them. […]

When a Tax Exemption Is Clear, Courts Must Enforce It Even Against the Government

Clear tax exemptions must be enforced as written; MERALCO recovered special import tax after insulating oil was treated as an exempt insulator. Tax exemptions are usually read strictly against the taxpayer, but that rule has an important limit: when the exemption is written in clear and unambiguous language, courts may not narrow it by interpretation. […]