When Tax Returns Are Not Enough to Prove Heirship in Property Disputes

Tax returns may support claims of filiation, but they do not outweigh civil registry records, credibility issues, or defects in a property transfer. Tax returns may help prove family status, but they do not automatically establish filiation, heirship, or ownership rights when civil registry records and the surrounding facts point the other way. For families […]

Citizenship Can Be Denied When Tax Records Do Not Prove Lawful Income

Citizenship was denied where tax records and business documents failed to prove lawful, sufficient income and exposed credibility defects. Tax compliance can decide more than a tax case: a foreign national seeking Philippine citizenship must prove lawful, sufficient, and credible income, and the Court may reject a naturalization petition when tax returns, business permits, and […]