Tax Evasion Cases Can Proceed Even Before the BIR Finalizes the Assessment

A BIR assessment protest does not stop criminal tax prosecution when the charge involves a fraudulent return or willful attempt to evade tax. A taxpayer cannot stop a criminal tax evasion case merely by protesting a BIR assessment or arguing that the exact tax deficiency has not yet been finally computed. When the government alleges […]

When Courts Cannot Avoid a Case by Calling It Political: The Casibang Rule on Judicial Duty

Casibang held that courts must decide legal rights despite political context, a doctrine useful in tax and regulatory disputes involving government discretion. Courts cannot refuse to decide a live legal dispute merely because the controversy arose in a politically charged setting. When private rights, legal qualifications, statutory remedies, or the validity of an official act […]

When an Appeal Becomes Pointless: Mootness Lessons for Tax Litigation

A final main judgment can render related petitions moot, warning taxpayers that ancillary motions cannot replace timely appeals in tax disputes. A pending appeal can die not because the party’s argument is weak, but because the main case has already become final and executory. For taxpayers, corporations, and litigants challenging government action, the practical lesson […]

When a Public Officer Is Already Dismissed, a Later Administrative Complaint May Become Moot

A later administrative complaint may be dismissed as moot when the officer was already removed from service with forfeiture of benefits in an earlier case. A second administrative complaint against a public officer may be dismissed as moot when the same respondent has already been found guilty in an earlier administrative case and removed from […]