Tax Refund Claims Can Survive Prescription Challenges When the BIR Merely Rehashes Old Arguments

Taxpayers defending refund claims should preserve prescription arguments early; the court denied the Commissioner’s MR and sustained a CGT refund. Taxpayers who have already secured a tax refund victory should be ready to defend that ruling against post-decision challenges, but a reconsideration motion that simply repeats previously rejected prescription arguments will not, by itself, justify […]

Fuel Sellers Can Recover Excise Tax on Petroleum Sold to Tax-Exempt Service Contractors

Fuel sellers may recover excise tax paid on petroleum later sold net of tax to exempt service contractors if payment, exemption, and tracing are proven. Petroleum importers and manufacturers that pay excise tax upfront may still recover that tax when the fuel is later sold net of excise tax to a buyer legally exempt from […]

When the BIR Overcollects Excise Tax, the Refund Clock Still Runs Fast

The Supreme Court allowed SMC’s excise tax refund but enforced the Tax Code’s two-year deadline, rejecting solutio indebiti and equity. Taxpayers may recover excise taxes collected under an invalid revenue regulation, but only if both the administrative and judicial refund claims are filed within the Tax Code’s strict two-year period. Even where the BIR’s legal […]

Tax Refunds Have a Hard Two-Year Deadline Even When the BIR Confirms the Exemption Later

A BIR ruling confirming tax exemption does not restart the two-year tax refund period; refund claims still run from tax payment date. Taxpayers and withholding agents cannot wait for a later BIR ruling before counting the deadline to recover taxes already paid. When a tax has been erroneously or excessively paid, the two-year period to […]

Tax Refund Claims Can Expire Before a Corporation Files Its Adjusted Final Return

A dissolved or merged corporation may lose a withholding tax refund if it waits for a final adjustment return instead of filing within the two-year refund period. Corporate taxpayers seeking a refund of creditable withholding taxes cannot wait for an adjusted final return when the corporation has already ceased operations through dissolution or merger. Where […]