When a Share Redemption Is Not a Taxable Dividend

Share redemption premiums are not automatically dividends. The Court allowed Goodyear’s refund and held no 15% FWT applied without unrestricted retained earnings. Companies that redeem shares from a foreign shareholder do not automatically owe dividend withholding tax merely because the redemption price exceeds par value. The controlling question is whether the payment is truly a […]

Dissenting Stockholders Cannot Force a Buyout Unless the Corporation Has Retained Earnings

Dissenting stockholders may demand fair value, but payment is enforceable only when the corporation has unrestricted retained earnings to protect creditors. A dissenting stockholder’s appraisal right is not an automatic right to immediate cash. Even after a valid objection to a corporate amendment and even after an appraisal committee fixes the fair value of the […]

Preferred Shares Are Not Automatic Cash Claims: Why Redemption and Dividends Depend on Corporate Law

Preferred shareholders cannot automatically compel redemption or dividends; payment depends on corporate law, board action, earnings, regulation, and timely enforcement. Preferred shareholders cannot treat redemption clauses and dividend language as automatic collection rights when the corporation has not validly declared dividends, lacks unrestricted retained earnings, or is legally restrained from redeeming the shares. For investors, […]

When a Company Buys Back a Shareholder’s Shares, the Dispute May Belong Before the SEC, Not the Regular Courts

Share buyout disputes tied to corporate shares may be intra-corporate controversies, not ordinary collection cases, requiring specialized corporate jurisdiction. A shareholder who is promised payment for the surrender or buyback of corporate shares may not always sue in the ordinary courts for collection. When the dispute arises from a stockholder’s agreement with the corporation involving […]