Self-Defense Fails When the Force Used Turns a Workplace Confrontation Into a Killing

The Supreme Court rejected self-defense but reduced murder to homicide after treachery was not proven in a fatal superior-subordinate shooting. A person who claims self-defense after a fatal confrontation must prove more than fear, anger, or a prior scuffle: unlawful aggression must be clearly shown, and the response must be reasonably necessary. Where an accused […]

When a Childโ€™s Clear Testimony Is Enough to Sustain a Rape Conviction

Credible child testimony, supported by medical findings, sustained a rape conviction despite alleged inconsistencies and rejected claims of voluntary surrender. A rape conviction may stand even when the defense attacks alleged inconsistencies in the child victimโ€™s account, so long as the testimony remains direct, credible, and materially consistent on the fact of sexual assault. For […]

When One Gunman Starts a Deadly Attack, All Conspirators May Answer for Murder

Group attackers may all face murder liability when conspiracy is proven through coordinated acts, even if each personโ€™s exact role is not separately shown. A person who joins an armed group attack may be convicted not only for the shot he personally fired, but for the killing carried out by the group when the evidence […]

When a Sudden Stab Becomes Murder: Treachery, Defense of a Relative, and Voluntary Surrender in Philippine Criminal Cases

A sudden knife attack during a scuffle was murder, not justified defense of a relative, where treachery was proven and voluntary surrender was rejected on appeal. A person who joins a fight to protect a relative cannot automatically claim justification if the evidence shows that the supposed victim-relative was not under unlawful aggression, and a […]

When Eyewitnesses and Dying Declarations Are Enough to Convict

Eyewitness testimony may survive minor inconsistencies, and a victimโ€™s dying identification may support conviction when made under awareness of impending death. A criminal conviction may stand even when the accused attacks a witness for inconsistencies, so long as the inconsistencies concern minor details and the witness remains credible on the essential facts: who committed the […]

When a Sudden Stabbing Is Homicide, Not Murder: The Proof Needed for Treachery

A sudden stabbing may be homicide, not murder, when treachery and premeditation are not proven beyond reasonable doubt. A killing is not automatically murder simply because the victim was unarmed, surprised, or unable to defend himself. For a conviction to rise from homicide to murder, the prosecution must prove the qualifying circumstance, such as treachery, […]