Suspicion Is Not Proof: Why Weak Circumstantial Evidence Cannot Sustain a Murder Conviction

Suspicion and vague conduct cannot sustain a murder conviction. The Supreme Court acquitted Mariano because the circumstantial evidence failed to prove guilt beyond reasonable doubt. A person accused of a serious crime cannot be convicted merely because the surrounding facts look suspicious. In Mariano, the Supreme Court reaffirmed a bedrock rule of criminal litigation: circumstantial […]

Weak Circumstantial Evidence Cannot Convict: Why Suspicion Is Not Proof Beyond Reasonable Doubt

The Supreme Court acquitted an accused in a rape with homicide case because the circumstantial evidence created suspicion, not proof beyond reasonable doubt. A criminal conviction cannot rest on suspicion, proximity, or objects loosely associated with the accused. Even in the most disturbing cases, the prosecution must prove guilt beyond reasonable doubt through evidence that […]