A Pasay property tax appeal win may still be reviewed by the Secretary of Finance when the city charter preserves administrative review authority.

A Pasay property owner who wins before the City Board of Tax Appeals may still face administrative review by the Secretary of Finance before the assessment fight is truly over. The ruling confirms that, at least under the Pasay City Charter provisions then in force, a favorable local tax appeal decision was not necessarily final against the government because the Finance Secretary retained power to reopen and review the Board’s decision.

Why This Case Matters to Property Taxpayers

Real property tax disputes often turn on procedure as much as valuation. A taxpayer may believe that once a city board lowers an assessment, the matter is finished. Enriquez teaches the opposite: where a statute preserves administrative review by the Department of Finance, the taxpayer’s victory before the local board can still be revisited. For property owners, this means that the legal route for contesting a real property tax assessment is not only about proving the correct value of the property, but also about knowing which government office has the final administrative say and when judicial review becomes available.

The controversy arose from the assessment of a Pasay City property owned by Pedro V. C. Enriquez. The property, located at the corner of Dominga and Flores Streets, was assessed by the Pasay City Assessor for taxation purposes. Enriquez appealed to the City Board of Tax Appeals, which reduced the assessment. Later, the Secretary of Finance reopened the Board’s resolution for review and cited compliance with the Department of Finance’s appraisal manual as a reason for the higher assessment. Enriquez then challenged the Secretary’s authority, arguing that the creation of the Court of Tax Appeals had removed that review power. The Supreme Court decided the case in Enriquez v. Secretary of Finance (G.R. No. L-24402).

The Core Doctrine: Administrative Review Survives Unless Congress Clearly Removes It

The Supreme Court rejected the taxpayer’s argument. It held that Republic Act No. 1125, which created the Court of Tax Appeals, did not divest the Secretary of Finance of authority to review decisions of the Pasay City Board of Tax Appeals concerning real estate assessment for tax purposes. The decisive point was congressional intent. The Court looked not only at the law creating the Court of Tax Appeals but also at later amendments to the Pasay City Charter under Republic Act No. 3275.

Those amendments changed how the City Board of Tax Appeals operated, including its composition and schedule of sessions. But the Court found it significant that Congress retained language allowing the Secretary of Finance, as Department Head, to declare decisions of the Board reopened for review. Because Congress amended the charter after the creation of the Court of Tax Appeals and still preserved that review mechanism, the Court concluded that the Secretary’s administrative review power had not been repealed by implication.

Administrative Review Is Different From Judicial Review

The Court drew an important line between two kinds of review. The Secretary of Finance’s authority was administrative in nature. It could be exercised by the Secretary on his own initiative or upon petition by either the City Assessor or the real estate owner. The Court of Tax Appeals, on the other hand, exercised judicial review by appeal under Republic Act No. 1125.

This distinction mattered because the two remedies served different roles. Administrative review by the Secretary could potentially spare the taxpayer from immediately going to court. But if the taxpayer remained dissatisfied after the administrative review, the taxpayer still retained the right to seek judicial review by appealing to the Court of Tax Appeals. In other words, the existence of one form of review did not necessarily cancel the other.

Why the Secretary of Finance Could Reopen a Favorable Local Board Decision

The Court treated the later amendments to the Pasay City Charter as strong evidence that Congress deliberately retained the Finance Secretary’s power. The amendments authorized the Board of Tax Appeals to hold sessions beginning in February to hear transmitted appeals and removed certain earlier language requiring approval by the Department before correcting erroneous or unjust assessments. But the same amended provision continued to state that the Board’s decision was final unless the Department Head declared the decision reopened for review.

For the Court, this was not accidental. It reasoned that if Congress wanted to eliminate the Secretary’s supervisory review power after creating the Court of Tax Appeals, it could have done so directly. Instead, Congress amended the relevant charter provisions and retained the Secretary’s power to reopen Board decisions. The Court therefore refused to infer a repeal that the statutory text did not clearly support.

No Equal Protection Violation From Pasay’s Special Charter Rule

Enriquez also argued that the Pasay rule amounted to unconstitutional class legislation because other cities allegedly did not have the same administrative review mechanism. The Court rejected that argument as well. It explained that the difference concerned the procedure given to taxpayers in Pasay City, not a discriminatory burden that placed them at an unfair disadvantage.

The Court also emphasized that municipal corporations are creatures of Congress. Because Congress creates and defines the powers of local government corporations, one city’s charter need not mirror another city’s charter in every procedural detail. The equal protection clause could not be invoked by a municipal corporation to complain that its charter contained a lesser grant of authority or autonomy compared with other municipal corporations. For taxpayers, this means that local tax procedure may depend heavily on the specific charter or statute governing the city involved.

Practical Impact for Real Property Tax Disputes

The immediate lesson is procedural caution. A taxpayer who secures a lower assessment before a city board should not assume that the case is closed if the governing law allows further administrative review. Government officials, including the assessor or the Secretary of Finance, may still have statutory avenues to revisit the result. Conversely, a taxpayer dissatisfied with the local board’s ruling may also use available administrative review procedures before going to court.

The broader lesson is that tax appeals require a careful map of the governing statute. A property owner should ask three questions at the start of any real property tax dispute: which office issued the assessment, which body hears the first appeal, and whether any statute gives a department head or court further review power. Missing one step can affect timing, jurisdiction, and the taxpayer’s available remedies.

For local governments, the ruling confirms that valuation disputes do not necessarily end at the local board level when the city charter preserves review by a national department head. For property owners, it underscores that a successful appeal may still need to be defended at the administrative review stage and, if necessary, before the Court of Tax Appeals.

How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help

Real property tax assessments can have immediate financial consequences for landowners, developers, lessors, and businesses with significant real estate holdings. Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists clients in evaluating assessments, preparing administrative protests and appeals, responding to reassessments, and pursuing judicial remedies where necessary. For help with real property tax disputes, local assessment appeals, or tax litigation strategy, visit MakatiLawFirm.com or consult our Tax Law and Litigation team.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *