When a Complaint’s Facts Matter More Than Its Label in Possession Disputes

A possession case turns on pleaded facts, not captions. The Court reinstated a lessee and restored a mandatory injunction in an ejectment dispute. Litigants in possession disputes cannot defeat a case simply by attacking the caption or technical label used in the complaint. When the pleaded facts show prior possession, disturbance, forcible entry, and continuing […]

Dissolving a Partnership Does Not Make Its Assets Judgment-Proof

Dissolved partnerships may still face collection against business assets during winding up, and courts cannot void another branch’s final judgment by collateral suit. Business owners cannot defeat creditors merely by dissolving a partnership, shifting assets through a chattel mortgage, or asking another court branch to undo a prior final judgment. Where the business continues in […]

When Non-Union Employees Cannot Be Charged Union Lawyer’s Fees

Non-union supervisors who received employer-extended wage increases could not be charged union lawyer’s fees without representation, consent, or CBA coverage. Employees who receive wage increases because their employer voluntarily extends benefits across the company cannot automatically be made to pay the union lawyer who negotiated those benefits for another group. The doctrine is simple but […]

When Losing Several Fingers Counts as Losing the Whole Hand in Work Injury Claims

Loss of several fingers may count as loss of the whole hand when the worker can no longer use it for ordinary work, supporting full disability compensation. A serious workplace injury is not measured only by what body parts remain, but by whether the worker can still perform the real functions of the injured limb. […]

When Work Aggravates Illness, Employers May Still Owe Compensation Even Without Total Disability

Work-related illness may be compensable when employment aggravates the condition, even without total disability or perfect procedural filing by the employee. Employees who become ill while in service may recover workmen’s compensation when their work aggravated or accelerated the illness, even if the disease was not originally caused by the job and even if the […]

When Prosecutors Are Not Ready, a Dismissed Criminal Case May Become an Acquittal

A speedy-trial dismissal after prosecution delay may operate as an acquittal, barring revival of the same case in tax or regulatory prosecutions. Accused persons in criminal cases may invoke the right to speedy trial not merely to postpone proceedings, but to end them; when the prosecution repeatedly fails to appear or present evidence, a dismissal […]

Late Appeal Records Should Not Automatically Kill a Meritorious Case

A late appeal record should not automatically defeat review when delay is slight, explained, and causes no substantial prejudice to the opposing party. Courts should not dismiss an appeal merely because a required appeal record was filed late when the delay is slight, the appellant did not intend to abandon the case, and no substantial […]

Payroll Deductions Are Not Tax-Like Priority Claims: Why Credit Unions Cannot Jump the Line Without a Clear Law

A credit union’s payroll deduction right does not create first-priority credit status. Mandamus fails without a clear legal right to priority. Credit unions and cooperatives cannot treat authorized salary deductions as a superior, tax-like claim against an employee’s wages unless the law clearly gives them that priority. Even when an employer is required to deduct […]