A General Denial Can Lose the Case Before Trial: The Pleading Lesson Every Taxpayer Should Know

A vague answer may admit key allegations and support judgment on the pleadings, making precise denials critical in tax and business litigation. A party who answers a complaint with a vague denial may be treated as having admitted the very facts he hoped to dispute. For taxpayers, property owners, and businesses facing collection suits, ejectment […]

Cargo Claims Fail When Delivery Records Show the Goods Left Custody Complete

Cargo damage claims fail without proof that the loss occurred in the defendant’s custody, especially when delivery records show contents were complete. A cargo damage claimant cannot recover from an arrastre operator merely by showing that goods were later found leaking or damaged at the consignee’s warehouse. When the delivery documents show that the shipment […]

When a Worker Dies on the Job, the Employer Must Rebut Compensability

Employee death during employment is presumed compensable unless the employer rebuts it. The Court restored death benefits for the worker’s family. Families of employees who die while still in the service of their employer are not required to prove every possible causal link between the death and the job before receiving compensation. Where death occurs […]

When a Lawyer Misses the Appeal Brief Deadline, the Client Is Not Automatically to Blame

A lawyer cannot let an appeal deadline lapse by blaming unpaid printing costs. Counsel must seek relief, inform the court, or protect the client’s case. A lawyer handling an appeal cannot excuse a missed brief deadline simply by saying the client failed to advance printing costs. If the lawyer remains counsel of record, the duty […]

When a Sheriff Delays Service and Demands Extra Money, Administrative Liability Follows

A sheriff who delayed summons service and collected unreceipted money was suspended, showing litigants can challenge court personnel misconduct. Court personnel who delay service of summons and demand money without issuing an official receipt may be disciplined even without a full-blown formal investigation, when the record already shows enough facts to determine administrative liability. For […]

When Marital Privilege Cannot Shield Falsified Documents

A spouse may testify against the other when alleged falsification directly injures conjugal rights and marital trust, defeating marital disqualification. A spouse may be allowed to testify against the other spouse when the alleged crime directly attacks the marriage itself, including a falsified deed that makes it appear that one spouse consented to the sale […]

A Weak Motion for Reconsideration Can Cost Your Tax Appeal

A generic motion for reconsideration may not stop appeal deadlines. The Court held that a pro forma motion can make a late appeal fatal. Taxpayers and litigants cannot rely on a bare or generic motion for reconsideration to stop appeal deadlines from running. When a motion merely says that the trial court failed to consider […]

When a Government Worker’s Final Compensation Award Cannot Be Reversed Later

A final workmen’s compensation award for a government gardener with tuberculosis could not be reversed after the review period expired. A final compensation award in favor of an injured or sick worker cannot be undone by a tribunal that has already lost jurisdiction over the case. For employees, especially those serving in government offices, the […]

A Case Cannot Be Dismissed Before the Facts Are Heard

Courts cannot dismiss civil cases on disputed facts without hearing evidence. Borje protects litigants from premature dismissal and denial of due process. Courts cannot short-circuit a lawsuit by dismissing it on disputed factual grounds before the parties are heard. When a complaint raises factual issues requiring proof, especially where both sides disagree on what happened, […]

No Shortcut Around Specialized Tax and Compensation Tribunals

Specialized tribunal rulings cannot be attacked through ordinary injunction suits when the law provides a specific appeal route. Forum choice is decisive. Courts of general jurisdiction cannot be used as a backdoor appeal from specialized tribunals. When the law assigns a dispute to a special body and provides a specific mode of review, a losing […]