GOCC employees in corporations without original charters may unionize under the Labor Code and seek certification elections, instead of being barred by civil service labor rules.

Employees of government-owned corporations created under the general corporation law may organize unions and demand a certification election under the Labor Code, because they are treated differently from civil service employees in government corporations with original legislative charters.

Why This Ruling Matters to Government Corporation Employees

The practical effect of the Trade Unions of the Philippines and Allied Services ruling is direct: not every employee working for a government-owned or controlled corporation is automatically governed by civil service labor rules. For workers, this can determine whether they may form or join a union, seek collective bargaining representation, and participate in a certification election. For management, it can determine whether labor relations are handled through the Labor Code and the Bureau of Labor Relations, or through civil service mechanisms.

The doctrine is best understood as the no original charter labor code rule. A government-owned or controlled corporation without an original legislative charter, and incorporated under the general corporation law, falls outside the civil service for this purpose. Its workers are therefore covered by the Labor Code provisions on union organization and certification elections.

Background: The Union Petition at the National Housing Corporation

The dispute arose when Trade Unions of the Philippines and Allied Services, or TUPAS, sought a certification election among the rank-and-file employees of the National Housing Corporation. NHC was a corporation organized in 1959 under Executive Order No. 399, otherwise known as the Uniform Charter of Government Corporations, and all of its shares were owned by government financial and social security institutions. TUPAS claimed that its members comprised the majority of NHC employees and sought recognition as their exclusive bargaining representative.

The Regional Office of the Department of Labor dismissed the petition, reasoning that NHC, being a government-owned or controlled corporation, was covered by civil service rules and that its employees were prohibited from forming, joining, or assisting a labor organization for collective bargaining purposes. The Bureau of Labor Relations initially reversed that dismissal and ordered a certification election, but the officer-in-charge later set aside that order. TUPAS then brought the controversy to the Court through a petition for certiorari (G.R. No. L-49677, May 4, 1989).

The Governing Distinction: Original Charter Versus General Corporation Law

The case turned on a constitutional distinction that may sound technical but has major labor consequences. Under the 1973 Constitution, the civil service included government-owned or controlled corporations generally. In an earlier NHC case involving illegal dismissal, that language had been read broadly. But the 1987 Constitution changed the formulation. It now covers government-owned or controlled corporations with original charters.

That change matters because a corporation with an original charter is created directly by Congress or by special law. A corporation incorporated under a general corporation statute, even if government-owned, stands on a different footing. The Court explained that the 1987 Constitution deliberately narrowed the civil service coverage to government corporations with original or legislative charters. By clear implication, government-owned or controlled corporations organized as subsidiaries or under the general corporation law are not automatically part of the civil service.

This distinction prevents an overbroad application of civil service rules to corporate entities that operate under the general corporate framework. It also resolves the labor relations question: if the employees are not governed by civil service labor restrictions, then their right to organize is governed by the Labor Code.

The Right to Self-Organization Applies in Both Public and Private Sectors

The ruling also emphasized that the right to self-organization is constitutionally protected. The Bill of Rights recognizes the right of people, including those employed in both the public and private sectors, to form unions, associations, or societies for purposes not contrary to law. The Constitution also directs the State to guarantee the rights of workers to self-organization, collective bargaining and negotiations, peaceful concerted activities, and, where allowed by law, the right to strike.

For government employees specifically, the Constitution recognizes that the right to self-organization shall not be denied. The Court connected that guarantee with the policy reasons discussed during the framing of the Constitution: government workers should not be deprived of a lawful forum to improve their terms and conditions of employment merely because the government is their employer.

Why the Certification Election Was Allowed

Because NHC was treated as a government-owned or controlled corporation without an original charter, there was no legal obstacle to holding a certification election among its workers. The employees were covered by the Labor Code, not by the civil service rules that would have barred the collective bargaining route invoked by TUPAS.

The Court therefore annulled and set aside the challenged Bureau of Labor Relations resolution and granted the petition. It ordered the conduct of a certification election among the affected employees of NHC in accordance with the applicable rules.

What This Means for Employees and Employers Today

For employees of government-linked corporations, the first question is not simply whether the government owns the entity. The more important question is whether the corporation has an original charter. If it does not, and if it was organized under the general corporation law, its employees may have Labor Code rights similar to those of private-sector employees, including the right to seek a certification election.

For HR managers and corporate counsel in government-owned or controlled corporations, this ruling is a warning against assuming that civil service rules automatically control every labor dispute. The corporationโ€™s legal origin must be examined. A mistaken classification can lead to improper denial of union rights, invalid labor relations decisions, and avoidable litigation before labor agencies and the courts.

For unions, the case provides a roadmap. A certification election petition involving a government-owned corporation should establish whether the corporation lacks an original legislative charter and whether the Labor Code certification election rules apply. That legal framing may determine whether the petition is dismissed at the threshold or allowed to proceed.

How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help

Ablola, Saribong & Gueco advises employees, unions, HR departments, and corporations in labor disputes, certification election issues, union representation questions, and government corporation employment matters. If your case involves a government-owned corporation, a disputed union petition, or uncertainty over whether civil service rules or the Labor Code applies, our Makati-based labor and litigation team can help assess the correct legal remedy and strategy. Visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult with our lawyers.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *