Workers hired by unauthorized managers may not be corporate employees. The ruling limits illegal dismissal liability to parties with valid hiring authority.

Employees hired by persons who had no authority from a corporation’s board cannot automatically treat the corporation itself as their employer. The controlling doctrine is simple but consequential: a corporation acts through its board of directors or through officers and agents validly authorized by that board; without that authority, even work performed inside a company’s business may not create an employer-employee relationship with the corporation.

Background: A Restaurant Takeover Created a Labor Dispute

The dispute arose from a family-owned restaurant corporation operating Fujiyama Hotel and Restaurant. Its original owners and managers were displaced after certain persons claiming to be stockholders obtained court orders connected with an intra-corporate controversy. During that period, the incoming group took over the restaurant’s operations and replaced almost all existing employees with new workers, many of whom later became the petitioners in the labor case.

After the court later ordered the return of management to the prior corporate officers, the original employees were reinstated. The replacement workers then claimed that they had been illegally dismissed and sought relief before the labor authorities. In Visayan v. NLRC (G.R. No. 69999, April 30, 1991), the question became whether the corporation itself could be held liable as their employer, even though the persons who hired them were later found to have lacked corporate authority.

The Supreme Court’s Core Ruling

The Supreme Court upheld the NLRC’s ruling that the replacement workers were not employees of the corporation. Their claim for illegal dismissal against the corporation failed because the people who engaged their services had no authority from the corporation’s board of directors to hire employees on its behalf.

The Court stressed that a corporation, being an artificial person, can act only through its board of directors or through officers and agents to whom the board has validly delegated authority. Without such authority, the acts of individuals purporting to represent the corporation do not bind the corporation. The Court therefore treated the workers as employees of the persons who hired them, not of Fujiyama Hotel and Restaurant itself.

The Corporate Authority Doctrine in Labor Cases

The decision is important because it applies a corporate law rule inside a labor dispute. In ordinary employment cases, the focus is often on control, payment of wages, hiring, and dismissal. Here, however, the Court first asked a threshold question: who had legal authority to hire for the corporation?

The Court relied on the rule that corporate powers are exercised by the board of directors. It also cited the principle that a board may delegate functions to officers, committees, or agents, but that delegation must be shown. A person dealing with a corporation cannot simply assume that anyone operating the business, occupying the premises, or acting like management has legal authority to bind the corporation.

This mattered because the replacement workers were not hired by the corporation’s authorized officers. They were hired by persons who had temporarily taken over the restaurant during an intra-corporate conflict and who did not have proper authority from the corporation’s board. The Court found that the corporation should not be made liable for employment contracts it did not authorize.

Why the Workers’ Illegal Dismissal Theory Failed

The workers argued that they had rendered service in the restaurant and were later removed when the previous management returned. But the Court held that this did not prove an employer-employee relationship with the corporation. The alleged employer must be the person or entity that validly hired the worker, paid or undertook to pay wages, exercised control, and had the authority to dismiss.

In this case, the act of hiring was the decisive problem. The people who engaged the petitioners’ services had no authority to hire for Fujiyama Hotel and Restaurant. Because their authority was defective, the employment relationship could not be imposed on the corporation. The Court also noted that the petitioners had been informed by a company officer that their appointments were only on a probationary basis, which weakened any claim of good faith or ignorance regarding the uncertainty of their status.

But the Workers Were Not Left Without a Possible Remedy

The Supreme Court did not say that the workers had no claim against anyone. Instead, it affirmed the NLRC’s direction to determine who among the petitioners were actually hired by the unauthorized managers and to identify what liabilities those hiring persons may have. The case was therefore not a total denial of labor protection; it was a clarification of the proper respondent.

This distinction is critical. A worker may have a claim for wages, benefits, or damages, but the correct defendant may not always be the corporation whose premises or business were used. Where a rogue faction, unauthorized manager, or claimant to control hires workers without board authority, liability may attach to the individuals who made the hiring decision rather than to the corporation itself.

The NLRC’s Power to Correct Its Own Error

The Court also sustained the NLRC’s authority to modify its earlier ruling. The workers argued that the corporation’s appeal should have been rejected on technical grounds involving the appeal bond and procedural defects. The Supreme Court rejected a rigid approach and emphasized that labor tribunals may correct, amend, or waive procedural errors in order to achieve substantial justice.

The Court reasoned that it would be unfair to impose a large monetary award on a corporation that was not truly the employer. Technical rules should not be used to sustain an erroneous judgment where the underlying facts show that the legal relationship necessary for liability does not exist.

Practical Impact for Business Owners and HR Managers

For business owners, the ruling is a warning to document authority clearly. Hiring authority should be set out in board resolutions, secretary’s certificates, employment manuals, delegation matrices, or written approvals. Where there is a dispute over corporate control, a company should immediately clarify who may hire, discipline, terminate, or bind the corporation in labor matters.

For HR managers, the decision shows why onboarding should never rely on informal instructions alone. A worker hired by a branch head, project manager, consultant, family member, or factional officer may later sue the corporation, but the corporation may resist liability if the alleged hirer lacked authority. Conversely, employees should verify who is actually hiring them and whether the person signing their appointment has corporate authority.

For employees, the key lesson is practical: if your employment arose during a takeover, management fight, receivership dispute, family corporation conflict, or unauthorized change in control, your claim may depend on proving not only that you worked, but that you were hired by someone authorized to bind the company.

How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help

Labor disputes involving corporate authority are rarely simple. They often sit at the intersection of employment law, intra-corporate disputes, board governance, and civil litigation. Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists corporations, managers, and employees in assessing whether an employer-employee relationship exists, identifying the proper parties, preparing labor pleadings, and structuring corporate authority documents to prevent future disputes. For advice on labor cases, unauthorized hiring, corporate control disputes, or NLRC proceedings, visit MakatiLawFirm.com.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *