A landlord’s ejectment case filed within one year from the last demand to vacate belongs in the Municipal Trial Court, not the Regional Trial Court.
A landlord who wants to remove a tenant after repeated demands to vacate must watch the one-year jurisdictional clock: when several demands are made, the period for filing unlawful detainer is counted from the last demand, and filing in the wrong court can void the entire case. The practical lesson of Labastida is severe but simple. Even a landlord with a registered title and a tenant allegedly occupying by month-to-month lease may lose years of litigation if the ejectment case is filed in the Regional Trial Court when the Municipal Trial Court has exclusive jurisdiction.
The Doctrine: The Last Demand Jurisdiction Rule in Ejectment
The case establishes what may be called the Last Demand Jurisdiction Rule. In unlawful detainer, the one-year period is not necessarily counted from the first time the landlord asked the tenant to leave. Where the landlord makes several demands to vacate, the period is reckoned from the last demand. The reason is practical: if the lessor does not sue immediately after a demand, the law may treat the lease as having been renewed or tolerated until the last effective demand.
This matters because jurisdiction in ejectment cases depends heavily on timing. If the unlawful withholding of possession has lasted for not more than one year from the last demand to vacate, the proper court is the Municipal Trial Court. The Regional Trial Court does not acquire jurisdiction merely because the complaint is titled as one for recovery of possession or damages, or because the property is valuable, or because the landlord claims ownership under a Torrens title.
Background: A Month-to-Month Lease Became a Jurisdictional Fight
The Deleste respondents were registered owners of a commercial lot in Iligan City covered by a transfer certificate of title. A portion of the lot was leased to Nonito and Constancia Labastida for a monthly rental of ₱200.00. The owners alleged that the Labastidas were month-to-month lessees, that they had made unauthorized constructions and subleases on the property, and that several verbal and written demands to vacate had been made. The last written demand was dated February 20, 1983.
On December 6, 1983, the owners filed an action in the Regional Trial Court of Iligan City, denominated as one for recovery of possession and damages with preliminary mandatory injunction. The trial court rendered judgment for the owners. The Court of Appeals affirmed. The Labastidas then challenged the jurisdiction of the Regional Trial Court before the Supreme Court in Labastida v. Court of Appeals (G.R. No. 110174, March 20, 1998).
The Label of the Complaint Did Not Control
The Supreme Court examined the allegations of the complaint rather than merely accepting the case title. Although the case was styled as one for recovery of possession, the substance of the pleading showed that the owners were seeking to eject lessees who allegedly refused to vacate after demands. The complaint alleged a lease on a month-to-month basis, repeated demands to vacate, and refusal to leave. Those allegations described unlawful detainer, not an ordinary accion publiciana.
This distinction controlled the outcome. Accion publiciana is an ordinary civil action for recovery of the better right to possess and generally belongs in the Regional Trial Court when the dispossession has lasted for more than one year or when the case does not fall within summary ejectment. Unlawful detainer, by contrast, is a special civil action designed to quickly restore possession when a tenant, lessee, or occupant unlawfully withholds possession after the expiration or termination of the right to possess.
Why the Regional Trial Court Had No Jurisdiction
The last written demand to vacate was dated February 20, 1983. The complaint was filed on December 6, 1983. That filing was still within one year from the last demand. Because the case was for unlawful detainer and was filed within the one-year period, it should have been filed in the Municipal Trial Court, not the Regional Trial Court.
The Supreme Court rejected the view that the one-year period should be counted from earlier verbal demands allegedly made in 1979. Where several demands are made, the last demand controls. The Court explained that if a landlord does not sue shortly after an earlier demand, it may be because the landlord has agreed to renew or tolerate the lease. The last demand is the point from which the tenant’s continued possession becomes the relevant unlawful withholding for purposes of the summary ejectment remedy.
Demand to Vacate Remains a Critical Requirement
The Court also addressed the argument that the tenants were estopped from questioning jurisdiction because they had earlier denied receiving the February 20, 1983 demand. The Court did not allow that procedural position to save the Regional Trial Court judgment. If the owners were to insist that no demand was served, then the ejectment case would still fail because Rule 70 required demand before an action could proceed against a tenant for violation of lease conditions or failure to vacate.
In other words, the owners could not have it both ways. If there was a valid last demand, the case was an unlawful detainer action filed within one year and belonged in the Municipal Trial Court. If there was no demand, then the required basis for the ejectment action was missing. Either way, the Regional Trial Court could not validly decide the case.
What This Means for Landlords, Tenants, and Property Owners
For landlords and commercial property owners, Labastida is a warning against filing possession cases based only on intuition or the title of the pleading. A complaint for recovery of possession may still be treated as unlawful detainer if the facts show a lease, expiration or termination of the right to possess, demand to vacate, and refusal to leave. Filing in the wrong court can render the proceedings null and void, even after a favorable judgment.
For tenants, the decision shows that jurisdictional objections can be powerful in ejectment disputes. A tenant who is sued in the wrong court may challenge the proceeding even when the landlord owns the property. Ownership is not always the immediate issue in ejectment. The urgent question is who has the better right to physical possession and whether the statutory procedure and forum were properly followed.
For businesses leasing commercial spaces, the case is especially relevant. Disputes over alleged unauthorized improvements, subleases, nonpayment, or termination of month-to-month arrangements must be handled with precision. The demand letter, the date it was served, the nature of the occupant’s possession, and the filing date will determine not only strategy but jurisdiction.
Practical Takeaway
The safest practice is to treat every demand to vacate as a legally significant event. A landlord should preserve proof of service, clearly state the basis for termination, and file in the correct court within the applicable period. A tenant should examine whether the demand was properly made, whether the action was timely, and whether the court has jurisdiction based on the actual allegations rather than the caption of the complaint.
Need Help With an Ejectment or Lease Dispute?
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists landlords, tenants, developers, property owners, and businesses in ejectment, unlawful detainer, accion publiciana, lease termination, and real property litigation. For case evaluation, demand-letter strategy, or defense against a possession case, visit MakatiLawFirm.com and consult with our litigation team.