A contract needs definite consent and corporate authority. Drafts, counteroffers, and unauthorized negotiations may not bind a company or justify damages.
Business owners cannot assume that a commercial deal is enforceable simply because negotiations were serious, documents were drafted, or a representative appeared to agree. A contract is perfected only when there is a definite meeting of minds on the object, price, and essential terms, and when the person accepting the offer has authority to bind the corporation.
Why This Case Matters to Business Owners
The ruling is important for companies that negotiate licensing deals, supply contracts, media rights, asset sales, settlement agreements, and other high-value commercial transactions. It draws a practical line between negotiation and obligation. Even when parties spend time, exchange drafts, discuss prices, and act as though a deal is close, the law still asks a stricter question: did the parties actually agree on the same thing, under the same terms, through persons with authority to bind them?
For business owners and corporate officers, the lesson is direct. A draft contract, a counterproposal, a handwritten note, or an apparent verbal understanding may not be enough. Where material terms remain unsettled, where the supposed acceptance changes the offer, or where the person negotiating still needs board approval, a court may find that no enforceable contract was ever perfected.
Background: A Dispute Over Film Broadcast Rights
ABS-CBN and Viva had earlier entered into a Film Exhibition Agreement giving ABS-CBN an exclusive right to exhibit several Viva films on television. The agreement also gave ABS-CBN a right of first refusal over future Viva films, subject to matching the terms offered by other buyers. Later, Viva, through Vicente del Rosario, offered ABS-CBN packages of films. ABS-CBN selected titles and proposed its own terms. Viva’s board later rejected the proposal, and Viva proceeded with a deal involving Republic Broadcasting Corporation, or RBS.
ABS-CBN filed suit to stop the airing of the disputed films and sought relief against Viva, Del Rosario, and RBS. The trial court held that there was no perfected contract between ABS-CBN and Viva, dismissed ABS-CBN’s complaint, and awarded damages in favor of RBS. The Court of Appeals substantially affirmed. The case reached the Supreme Court in ABS-CBN Broadcasting Corporation v. Court of Appeals (G.R. No. 128690, January 21, 1999).
The Supreme Court’s Ruling: No Perfected Contract Was Formed
The Supreme Court agreed that ABS-CBN and Viva did not have a perfected contract over the disputed package of films. The Court emphasized the Civil Code rule that a contract exists only when the essential requisites concur: consent of the contracting parties, a certain object, and a cause or consideration. Consent requires a meeting of minds, and acceptance must be absolute. A qualified acceptance is not acceptance at all; it is a counteroffer.
On the facts, ABS-CBN did not simply accept Viva’s offer. It selected films, proposed different terms, and dealt with a draft arrangement that still required approval. The alleged agreement was not a final, binding contract because material terms were still uncertain and the supposed acceptance varied the terms of the original offer. The Supreme Court therefore treated the parties’ exchanges as negotiations, not as the birth of an enforceable contract.
The Corporate Authority Rule: Not Every Negotiator Can Bind the Company
The Court also relied on a corporate-law principle that remains highly relevant today: a corporation acts through its board of directors, unless authority has been validly delegated. Corporate powers are exercised by the board. Officers may bind the corporation only when they have actual or apparent authority, and that authority must be shown with care when the transaction is substantial.
Del Rosario’s participation in negotiations did not automatically mean that Viva was already bound. The evidence showed that the matter was still subject to approval by Viva’s board. Since the board rejected the proposed deal, the Court found no basis to treat the negotiations as an enforceable commitment of Viva. This is especially significant for corporate transactions where presidents, managers, or business development officers negotiate terms but remain subject to board approval or internal clearance.
Rights of First Refusal Must Still Be Exercised Under Clear Terms
The earlier agreement gave ABS-CBN a right of first refusal. But that did not mean ABS-CBN could compel Viva to accept a different package or revised commercial terms. A right of first refusal generally allows the holder to match a bona fide third-party offer under the same terms. It does not, by itself, create a new contract when the parties disagree on price, titles, scope, reruns, or other material conditions.
This distinction matters in real estate, franchising, media licensing, distribution, and shareholder arrangements. A right of first refusal is powerful, but it is not a blank check. The holder must match the offer according to the agreed mechanism. If the response changes material terms, the response may be treated as a counteroffer rather than a valid exercise of the right.
Why the Damages Award Against ABS-CBN Was Reversed
Although the Supreme Court agreed that ABS-CBN had no perfected contract with Viva, it reversed the damages awarded to RBS. The Court held that RBS could not recover actual damages from ABS-CBN merely because it spent money to post a counterbond. The filing of a counterbond was RBS’s procedural response to the injunction situation, not a loss directly chargeable to ABS-CBN as a proven legal wrong.
The Court also rejected attorney’s fees. Under the Civil Code, attorney’s fees are not awarded as a matter of course. They require factual, legal, and equitable justification. They are not meant to reimburse every successful litigant for the cost of defending a case. Because the award lacked sufficient basis, it could not stand.
Moral and Exemplary Damages: Corporations Face a Higher Barrier
The ruling also clarified the limits of moral damages for corporations. The Court recognized that a corporation, being an artificial person, cannot experience physical suffering, wounded feelings, anxiety, or similar human emotions. While a corporation may in some circumstances recover moral damages if its reputation is debased, the Court found no adequate proof that ABS-CBN acted with malice or bad faith.
Exemplary damages were likewise unavailable. Such damages are imposed by way of example or correction for the public good, but they require a legally recognized basis and proof of wanton, fraudulent, reckless, oppressive, or malevolent conduct. The Court did not find that ABS-CBN’s decision to litigate crossed that line. It observed that ABS-CBN honestly believed in the merits of its position after serious negotiations and after submission of a draft contract.
Practical Impact: How Businesses Should Document Deals
The practical message is simple: if the deal matters, remove ambiguity before anyone acts. Businesses should make clear whether a term sheet is binding or non-binding, whether an offer is subject to board approval, who has authority to accept, what exact assets or rights are covered, and whether acceptance must match all terms without modification. If a right of first refusal is involved, the procedure for exercising it should be precise.
The ruling also warns against relying on informal notes, partial drafts, or conversations to prove a final commercial contract. These may show negotiation, but they may not prove consent. A party that wants enforceability should insist on a written agreement signed by authorized representatives, with corporate approvals attached or expressly waived when legally permissible.
What This Means for Litigation Strategy
For plaintiffs, the case shows that suing on an alleged contract requires more than proof that discussions happened. The plaintiff must prove a definite offer, absolute acceptance, authority, and agreement on material terms. For defendants, it provides a roadmap for resisting claims based on unfinished negotiations: identify the counteroffers, unsettled terms, missing approvals, and lack of authority.
For companies defending against damages claims, the ruling is equally useful. A failed injunction or dismissed complaint does not automatically entitle the opposing party to actual, moral, exemplary damages, or attorney’s fees. Each category must be independently justified under the Civil Code and supported by evidence.
Commercial Litigation Help from Ablola, Saribong & Gueco
Contract disputes often turn on the details: who negotiated, what was offered, what was accepted, what remained unresolved, and who had authority to bind the company. Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists businesses, shareholders, property owners, and individuals in evaluating contract claims, enforcing commercial rights, defending against damages claims, and structuring agreements to avoid costly disputes. For legal assistance with contract litigation, corporate authority issues, injunctions, or commercial disputes, visit MakatiLawFirm.com.