Corporate officers removed from board-created positions may have intra-corporate disputes, not NLRC illegal dismissal claims, if the issue is corporate office removal.
A corporate officer removed from a board-created position cannot automatically convert the dispute into an illegal dismissal case before the Labor Arbiter. When the claim is rooted in the person’s status as a corporate officer and in the corporation’s internal power to appoint or remove that officer, the controversy is intra-corporate in nature, not an ordinary employer-employee dispute.
Why This Matters to Corporate Officers and Employers
The most practical lesson from Union Motors is that the title and function of the person matter. A manager may look like an employee for day-to-day operational purposes, but if the position is created by the by-laws, filled by board action, and treated as part of the corporation’s internal governance structure, disputes over removal may fall outside ordinary labor jurisdiction.
For business owners, this ruling is a jurisdictional shield against labor claims that are, in substance, boardroom disputes. For executives, corporate secretaries, treasurers, assistant treasurers, and other by-law officers, it is a warning that remedies may depend not merely on whether they received compensation or performed work, but on whether their office was corporate in character.
Background of the Dispute
Union Motors Corporation appointed Priscilla Go as Administrative and Personnel Manager in 1982. During a later corporate reorganization, she was appointed Assistant to the President and Administrative and Personnel Manager by the board of directors. She also became Assistant Treasurer. The relationship deteriorated after internal memoranda placed her under the supervision of the Vice-President and Treasurer, and after management sought changes in reporting lines and office arrangements.
Go claimed that she had been constructively and illegally dismissed. She filed a complaint before the Labor Arbiter for reinstatement, backwages, 13th month pay, allowances, bonuses, moral and exemplary damages, and attorney’s fees. Union Motors and the Cua officers denied illegal dismissal and argued that the dispute was not a labor case but an intra-corporate controversy involving removal from a corporate office. The case reached the Supreme Court in Union Motors Corporation v. NLRC (G.R. No. 125931, September 16, 1999).
The Corporate Officer Jurisdiction Doctrine
The doctrine may be called the Corporate Officer Jurisdiction Doctrine: when the controversy concerns the appointment, tenure, or removal of a corporate officer, and the right asserted arises from corporate law, the by-laws, or board action, the case is intra-corporate. It does not become an ordinary illegal dismissal case merely because the officer also performed managerial functions or received compensation.
At the time of the Union Motors ruling, intra-corporate controversies fell within the jurisdiction of the Securities and Exchange Commission. After the Securities Regulation Code, that jurisdiction was transferred to the proper Regional Trial Courts designated to hear intra-corporate disputes. The core principle remains useful today: jurisdiction is determined by the relationship of the parties and the nature of the controversy, not by the label placed on the complaint.
Why the Court Treated Go as a Corporate Officer
The Court examined the corporation’s by-laws and board records. Under the Corporation Code then in force, corporations were required to have a president, secretary, and treasurer, but were also allowed to create other offices as provided by the by-laws. Union Motors’ by-laws permitted the board to appoint other officers as necessary and proper. The board appointed Go as Assistant to the President and Personnel and Administrative Manager, while the Secretary’s Certificate showed that she was also appointed Assistant Treasurer.
Go argued that not all corporate offices were listed in the by-laws and that her position was not truly corporate in nature. The Court rejected that narrow view. It held that when the by-laws authorize the board to create and fill other necessary offices, and the board actually appoints a person to such office, the resulting position may be treated as a corporate office. A Secretary’s Certificate showing the board appointment was enough to establish the corporate character of the appointment in the absence of contrary evidence.
Why the Labor Arbiter and NLRC Had No Jurisdiction
The Court emphasized that Go’s complaint was essentially about her removal from a corporate office. Her claims for reinstatement, backwages, separation pay, damages, and attorney’s fees all flowed from that alleged wrongful removal. Because the controversy concerned the legality of her removal as a corporate officer, it was intra-corporate. The Labor Arbiter and the NLRC therefore had no jurisdiction over the subject matter.
This point is important because jurisdiction cannot be created by waiver, silence, delay, or participation in the proceedings. Union Motors was faulted for not objecting earlier, but the Court held that estoppel could not make the NLRC competent to decide a case that the law placed elsewhere. A tribunal without jurisdiction cannot acquire it simply because the parties argued the case before it.
The Result of the Case
The Court granted the petition for certiorari and prohibition. It reversed the NLRC resolutions that had awarded Go separation pay, backwages, and other monetary reliefs. The illegal dismissal ruling was set aside because the NLRC had acted without jurisdiction. The dismissal was without prejudice to Go’s right to seek relief in the proper forum, but the labor judgment itself could not stand.
Practical Impact for Companies and Executives
For corporations, the ruling underscores the importance of clear by-laws, properly documented board appointments, and accurate Secretary’s Certificates. If a position is intended to be a corporate office, the corporation should ensure that the by-laws authorize the office or authorize the board to create additional offices. Board resolutions should clearly identify the office, the authority for appointment, and the scope of powers.
For executives, the ruling shows that the label manager, consultant, treasurer, assistant treasurer, vice-president, or administrative head is not conclusive by itself. The question is whether the role is tied to corporate governance and board appointment. A person claiming illegal dismissal must first determine whether the dispute is truly about employment or about the removal of a corporate officer.
For HR managers, this case is especially relevant when handling senior officers who wear two hats. Some individuals may have both employment functions and corporate officer status. Before issuing termination papers, accepting resignations, or defending an NLRC complaint, the company should review the articles, by-laws, board resolutions, Secretary’s Certificates, job descriptions, and actual functions performed.
What a Prospective Client Should Take Away
If you are a removed officer asking whether you can file an illegal dismissal case, the answer depends on the legal character of your position. If your office was created by the by-laws or by board action under authority of the by-laws, your case may belong in an intra-corporate proceeding rather than before the Labor Arbiter. If you are a company defending an NLRC complaint filed by a former officer, the first issue may not be just cause or due process, but jurisdiction.
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists corporations, directors, officers, shareholders, and executives in disputes involving corporate officer removal, NLRC claims, board authority, intra-corporate controversies, and related employment litigation. For guidance on whether your dispute belongs before the labor tribunals or the commercial courts, visit MakatiLawFirm.com.