A court clerk was fined for notarizing a petition she also signed, reinforcing that oath officers must remain neutral and separate from the document.

A court employee acting as a notary or oath-administering officer cannot notarize, authenticate, or administer an oath on a document in which she is herself one of the signatories. The rule protects the integrity of notarized documents by separating two acts that must remain independent: signing an instrument and officially certifying the oath or acknowledgment connected to that instrument.

The Practical Rule: A Signatory Cannot Be the Notary for the Same Instrument

For ordinary litigants, public school employees, barangay officials, business owners, and anyone preparing sworn complaints or petitions, the lesson is straightforward: the person who signs a sworn document as a party or supporter should not be the same person who notarizes or administers the oath over that document. Even if the person has authority to administer oaths, that authority cannot be used to validate a document in which the officer has a personal participation as a signatory.

This matters because notarization is not a mere clerical formality. A notarial act gives a document a higher level of credibility. It tells courts, government offices, and private parties that the signer appeared before an authorized officer, acknowledged the document, or swore to its truth in the manner required by law. When the notary is also a signatory, the notary is no longer a neutral certifying officer. The official act becomes tainted by self-interest.

Background: A Petition, a Court Clerk, and a Notarial Complaint

Estela P. Valles filed a sworn administrative complaint against Nila Arzaga-Quijano, Clerk of Court II of the Municipal Circuit Trial Court of Araceli-Dumaran, Palawan. The complaint accused Arzaga-Quijano of malfeasance, abuse of authority, and graft and corrupt practices after she allegedly joined around 200 persons in signing a petition before the Palawan Division Superintendent of the Department of Education, Culture and Sports seeking Valles’ removal as teacher of Araceli National High School.

The key issue was not merely that Arzaga-Quijano signed the petition. The complaint centered on the fact that the petition was subscribed and sworn before her, despite her being one of its signatories. In other words, she participated in the document as a signer and then acted as the officer before whom the document was sworn. The case reached the Supreme Court as an administrative matter involving court personnel (A.M. No. P-99-138, November 18, 1999).

The Respondent’s Explanation

Arzaga-Quijano admitted that her signature appeared among the signatures in the petition-letter. However, she argued that the signatures were part of the body of the petition and not the signatures of the petitioners in the formal sense. She claimed that the petition showed the signatory as the Parents Teachers Community Association of Araceli National High School, not each person whose name appeared on the document.

She further explained that she believed the association president was the true signatory representative and that she administered the oath under that understanding. She also described the circumstances as rushed, saying the association president appeared before her at around noon, with people outside waiting and office conditions adding to the haste. She claimed the administrative complaint was connected to a punitive motive against her for being one of the supporters of the move to oust Valles from the school.

The Supreme Court’s Ruling: Negligence in Observing the Notarial Law

The Supreme Court imposed a fine of P2,000.00 on Arzaga-Quijano for lack of diligence in the observance of the Notarial Law. The Court did not need to find the broad accusations of graft or corrupt practices to impose discipline. It focused on the notarial violation: an officer authorized to administer oaths cannot subscribe a document in which she is one of the affiants.

The Court applied Article 22 of the Notarial Law, which states that no notary may authenticate a contract containing a provision in favor of the notary, or in favor of certain relatives within the prohibited degrees. While the cited provision refers to contracts and interested notaries, the Court used the principle behind the rule: a notarial officer must not act in a matter where the officer’s own interest or participation compromises impartiality.

The Court emphasized that being one of the signatories to the petition meant Arzaga-Quijano could not administer the oath with reference to that same document. She could not sign the document and then subscribe it herself. The Court described the signing of an instrument and the authentication of the same instrument as two different acts that must be performed by different individuals.

Why the Court Treated This as a Serious Notarial Integrity Issue

The ruling is important because it explains the public function of notarization. The function of a notary public includes guarding against illegal or immoral arrangements. That purpose would be defeated if the notary were also a signatory to the instrument, because the notary would have an interest in sustaining the validity of her own act.

In practical terms, the Court saw the danger clearly: if a notary signs a document and later notarizes it, the officer becomes both participant and certifier. The notary may then be placed in an inconsistent position, with a personal incentive to defend the document’s validity. The safeguard meant to minimize fraud is weakened precisely at the point where public confidence is supposed to be strongest.

What This Means for Sworn Complaints, Petitions, and Government Filings

For anyone preparing a petition, affidavit, complaint, board certification, undertaking, or other sworn paper, the safer rule is simple: use a notary or oath-administering officer who is completely separate from the transaction. The notary should not be a party, beneficiary, affiant, witness with personal interest, or signatory whose own participation is validated by the notarial act.

This is especially relevant for local government offices, court personnel, schools, homeowners’ associations, cooperatives, companies, and civic organizations where one person may be tempted to act both as organizer and certifying officer. Convenience is not a defense. Haste is not a defense. A rushed office setting does not excuse the failure to observe the independence required in notarization.

For litigants, the ruling also provides a useful way to challenge suspicious notarizations. If a notarized document was certified by someone who also signed it or personally benefited from it, the notarization may be vulnerable to attack. Depending on the context, that defect may support an administrative complaint, a challenge to the document’s evidentiary value, or further legal action where fraud or bad faith is present.

The Broader Doctrine: Notarial Neutrality Protects Public Trust

The doctrine may be called the notarial neutrality rule: a person authorized to administer oaths must remain separate from the document being sworn to or acknowledged. The notary’s function is not simply to stamp paper. The notary lends public character to a private act. That public character depends on independence, impartiality, and faithful compliance with notarial rules.

For court personnel, the standard is even stricter. Court employees are expected to observe the law with care because their conduct reflects on the judiciary. A seemingly small notarial shortcut can become an administrative offense when it undermines the reliability of sworn documents and the public’s confidence in court officers.

How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help

Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists clients in civil litigation, administrative complaints, notarial issues, document review, and challenges involving defective affidavits, sworn statements, petitions, contracts, and corporate instruments. If you are dealing with a disputed notarized document, an irregular affidavit, or a government filing that may have been improperly sworn, our litigation team can help assess the legal effect of the defect and the remedies available. Visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult our team in Makati City.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *