RR No. 7-2001 sets BIR compromise settlement rules, covered and excluded cases, minimum rates, documents, and approval process for tax liabilities.
Taxpayers with delinquent accounts, disputed BIR assessments, civil tax cases, collection cases, and certain pre-assessment disputes received a clearer route for compromise settlement, but only if they fall within the allowed cases, meet the stated grounds, submit the required documents, and pay at least the prescribed minimum compromise rates. RR No. 7-2001 matters immediately to businesses because it sets the specific grounds, minimum percentages, documentary requirements, and approval process for settling internal revenue tax liabilities with the Bureau of Internal Revenue.
What RR No. 7-2001 Changed
RR No. 7-2001 further implements Sections 7(c), 204(A), and 290 of the Tax Code of 1997 on compromise settlement of internal revenue tax liabilities. It amends RR No. 6-2000 and confirms the authority of the Commissioner of Internal Revenue to compromise certain outstanding receivable accounts and disputed assessments with the BIR.
The most important change is that the regulation identifies the types of BIR cases that may be compromised, the cases that are excluded, the grounds that justify compromise, the minimum rates based on the basic assessed tax, and the offices that must approve the settlement. This is highly relevant to taxpayers searching for BIR compromise settlement, delinquent account settlement, disputed assessment compromise, financial incapacity compromise, and doubtful validity of assessment.
Tax Cases That May Be Compromised
RR No. 7-2001 allows compromise settlement for several categories of internal revenue tax liabilities, subject to the taxpayer’s compliance with the regulatory basis for compromise. The covered cases include delinquent accounts; cases under administrative protest pending in the Regional Offices, Revenue District Offices, Legal Service, Large Taxpayer Service, Collection Service, Enforcement Service, and other offices in the National Office; civil tax cases being disputed before the courts such as the Metropolitan Trial Court, Regional Trial Court, Court of Tax Appeals, Court of Appeals, and Supreme Court; collection cases filed in courts; criminal violations other than those already filed in court or those involving criminal tax fraud; and cases covered by pre-assessment notices where the taxpayer does not agree with the audit office findings as confirmed by the review office.
For business owners and CFOs, this means a compromise may be available not only after a tax liability has become delinquent, but also while a protested assessment or certain civil tax cases remain pending. However, compromise is not automatic. The taxpayer must qualify under one of the accepted grounds and must comply with the rate, document, and approval requirements.
Cases Excluded From Compromise Settlement
RR No. 7-2001 expressly excludes several cases from compromise settlement. These are withholding tax cases; criminal tax fraud cases; criminal violations already filed in court; delinquent accounts with duly approved schedules of installment payments; cases where final reports of reinvestigation or reconsideration have already been issued resulting in a reduction of the original assessment and the taxpayer agrees with the decision; and cases that have become final and executory after final judgment of a court.
This exclusion is critical for withholding agents. A corporation that failed to withhold, remit, or properly report withholding taxes cannot assume that the compromise mechanism under RR No. 7-2001 is available. Taxpayers with approved installment schedules should also note that the regulation excludes delinquent accounts already covered by duly approved installment payments.
Grounds for Compromise: Doubtful Validity and Financial Incapacity
The Commissioner may compromise internal revenue tax liabilities on two broad grounds: doubtful validity of the assessment and financial incapacity.
A compromise based on doubtful validity may be accepted when there is reasonable doubt as to the validity of the assessment. RR No. 7-2001 identifies several situations, including jeopardy assessments, arbitrary assessments appearing to be based on presumptions and lacking legal or factual basis, failure to protest because the taxpayer allegedly did not receive the assessment or preliminary assessment, failure to request reinvestigation or reconsideration within 30 days from receipt of the final assessment notice where the assessment appears legally or factually deficient, failure to elevate an adverse decision to the Court of Tax Appeals within 30 days where the assessment appears legally or factually deficient, assessments issued on or after January 1, 1998 where the demand notice allegedly failed to comply with Section 228 formalities, and assessments based on the Best Evidence Obtainable Rule where sufficient and competent evidence may dispute the assessment.
A compromise based on financial incapacity may be accepted where the taxpayer can show that the corporation has ceased operations or has been dissolved; the taxpayer has a surplus or earnings deficit resulting in impairment of original capital by at least 50%; the taxpayer has a net worth deficit computed by deducting total liabilities, net of deferred credits, from total assets, net of prepaid expenses, deferred charges, pre-operating expenses, and appraisal increases in fixed assets, based on the latest audited financial statements; the taxpayer is a compensation income earner with no other income and no leviable or distrainable assets other than the family home; or the taxpayer has been granted a moratorium or suspension of payments by the SEC or competent tribunal, or has otherwise been declared bankrupt or insolvent.
Minimum Compromise Rates Under RR No. 7-2001
The regulation fixes minimum compromise percentages based on the basic assessed tax, reckoned on a per tax type assessment basis. For financial incapacity, an individual whose only income is employment income and whose monthly salary is P10,500 or less if single, or whose salary together with the spouse is P21,000 per month or less if married, may be subject to a minimum compromise rate of 10%. An individual without any source of income is also subject to a minimum compromise rate of 10%.
For taxpayers with zero net worth or negative net worth, the minimum compromise rate is 10%. For dissolved corporations, the minimum rate is 20%. For non-operating companies, the minimum rate is 10% if the company has been non-operating for three years or more as of the date of application for compromise settlement, and 20% if non-operating for less than three years. If the taxpayer has a surplus or earnings deficit resulting in impairment of original capital by at least 50%, the minimum rate is 20%. If the taxpayer is under moratorium or suspension of payments, or has been declared insolvent or bankrupt, the minimum rate is 10%.
For doubtful validity of the assessment, the minimum compromise rate is 40% of the basic assessed tax. A taxpayer may request a compromise rate lower than 40%, but the request must be in writing and must state the legal and factual reasons supporting the lower rate. For doubtful-validity applications involving an offer below the 40% minimum, prior approval by the National Evaluation Board is required.
The same prescribed minimum percentages also apply to compromise settlements of assessments consisting solely of increments, such as surcharge and interest, based on the total amount assessed.
Documentary Requirements for a Valid Application
RR No. 7-2001 requires specific documents depending on the basis for the compromise. A taxpayer relying on low compensation income must submit a certification from the employer showing the prevailing monthly salary, including allowances, and a sworn statement that the taxpayer has no other source of income other than employment.
A taxpayer claiming no income from any source must submit a sworn statement that he or she derives no income from any source whatever. A taxpayer relying on financial incapacity under the corporate or financial-condition categories must submit the latest audited financial statements or audited Account Information Form filed with the BIR. For dissolved corporations, the Notice of Dissolution submitted to the SEC or a similar or equivalent document must also be submitted. For taxpayers under moratorium, suspension of payments, bankruptcy, or insolvency, a copy of the order granting the moratorium or suspension of payments, or the order of bankruptcy or insolvency, must be submitted.
For compromises based on financial incapacity, the Commissioner will not consider the offer unless the taxpayer waives in writing the privilege of secrecy of bank deposits under Republic Act No. 1405 or other applicable laws. That waiver authorizes the Commissioner to inquire into the taxpayer’s bank deposits. This is a major compliance point for corporations and individuals considering a financial incapacity compromise.
Approval Process: NEB and REB
Compromise settlements within the jurisdiction of the National Office must be approved by the National Evaluation Board, composed of the Commissioner and the four Deputy Commissioners. All decisions of the National Evaluation Board, whether favorable or unfavorable, must have the concurrence of the Commissioner.
For assessments issued by Regional Offices involving basic deficiency taxes of P500,000 or less, and for minor criminal violations discovered by Regional and District Offices, approval is delegated to the Regional Evaluation Board. The Regional Evaluation Board is chaired by the Regional Director and includes the Assistant Regional Director, Chief of the Legal Division, Chief of the Assessment Division, Chief of the Collection Division, and the Revenue District Officer having jurisdiction over the taxpayer-applicant.
However, if the compromise offer is less than the prescribed minimum rates, approval must always come from the National Evaluation Board. If the offer meets the conditions for availment under Sections 3, 4, and 5 of the regulations, the case is considered provisionally closed on the day the compromise amount is fully paid, and approval becomes a matter of course on the part of the approving authority.
Effectivity and Compliance Timing
RR No. 7-2001 takes effect fifteen days after publication in any newspaper of general circulation. Taxpayers evaluating compromise should also take note of the relevant 30-day periods referenced in the regulation for requests for reinvestigation or reconsideration from receipt of the final assessment notice, and for elevation to the Court of Tax Appeals from receipt of an adverse decision of the Commissioner or authorized representative.
The regulation is dated July 31, 2001. It also treats the term assessment as including the preliminary assessment notice issued as of June 30, 2001 by the appropriate review office, but not the post-reporting notice issued by the head of the investigating unit.
Practical Steps for Businesses, CFOs, and Tax Managers
Businesses with open BIR assessments should first classify the case: delinquent account, protested assessment, civil tax case, collection case, pre-assessment notice dispute, or criminal violation. The taxpayer must then check whether the case is excluded, especially if it involves withholding tax, criminal tax fraud, a criminal case already filed in court, an approved installment schedule, or a final and executory court judgment.
Next, management should determine the proper ground for compromise. If the issue is doubtful validity, the taxpayer must prepare a legal and factual explanation showing why the assessment lacks basis, was arbitrary, failed to comply with Section 228 formalities, resulted from a jeopardy assessment, or may be defeated by sufficient and competent evidence. If the issue is financial incapacity, the taxpayer must prepare financial statements, sworn statements, employer certifications, SEC dissolution documents, or court or SEC orders, as applicable.
The taxpayer should also compute the minimum offer. For doubtful validity, the starting point is 40% of the basic assessed tax unless a lower rate is specifically justified in writing and approved by the National Evaluation Board. For financial incapacity, the rate may be 10% or 20% depending on the taxpayer’s condition. Where the assessment consists only of increments such as surcharge or interest, the percentage applies to the total amount assessed.
Finally, taxpayers should prepare for bank deposit waiver requirements if claiming financial incapacity. A financial incapacity compromise is not merely a paper request; it allows the Commissioner to inquire into bank deposits once the required waiver is executed.
How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Assist
RR No. 7-2001 is a practical tool for resolving certain BIR liabilities, but it is also technical. A weak compromise application can fail because the case is excluded, the wrong ground is invoked, the minimum rate is miscomputed, or the documentary requirements are incomplete.
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists businesses, business owners, CFOs, accountants, and in-house counsel in evaluating BIR assessments, preparing compromise settlement applications, drafting legal and factual justifications for doubtful validity, compiling financial incapacity documentation, and coordinating tax dispute strategy from administrative protest through litigation. For assistance with BIR compromise settlement, disputed assessments, delinquent tax accounts, or tax litigation strategy, visit MakatiLawFirm.com.