Local governments may tax franchise receipts of GOCCs when prior exemptions were withdrawn and proprietary franchise activity is involved.

The Local Franchise Tax Rule confirms that a government-owned corporation may still face local business taxes when it operates through a franchise and performs proprietary, revenue-generating functions. For cities and government corporations, the practical lesson is direct: an exemption in an old charter is not enough if the Local Government Code has withdrawn that exemption and the activity being taxed is the exercise of a franchise, not ownership by the national government.

Background: The Dispute

National Power Corporation supplied electricity to residents of Cabanatuan City and had been paying local franchise taxes assessed under a city ordinance. It later refused to continue paying, arguing that it was a government-owned and controlled corporation, that its charter exempted it from taxes, and that local governments had no authority to tax instrumentalities of the national government.

The City of Cabanatuan filed a collection suit to recover unpaid franchise taxes, while National Power Corporation maintained that its tax privileges survived. The dispute reached the Supreme Court in National Power Corporation v. City of Cabanatuan (G.R. No. 149110, April 9, 2003), after the Court of Appeals sustained the city’s power to collect.

The Supreme Court’s Ruling

The Court upheld Cabanatuan City’s authority to impose the local franchise tax. It held that Section 137 of the Local Government Code authorizes provinces, cities, and municipalities within Metro Manila to impose a tax on businesses enjoying a franchise, subject to the statutory rate limitations.

The Court rejected the argument that National Power Corporation was immune merely because it was government-owned. A franchise tax is not imposed on ownership by the national government. It is imposed on the privilege of exercising a franchise, meaning the special authority granted by the State to do business or perform activities that otherwise require governmental permission.

The Court also emphasized that Section 193 of the Local Government Code withdrew prior tax exemptions or incentives granted to natural or juridical persons, including government-owned or controlled corporations, except for specific entities expressly preserved by law. Since National Power Corporation did not fall within those statutory exceptions, its former tax exemption could not defeat the city’s ordinance.

Key Legal Principles Established

The decision establishes the Local Franchise Tax Rule: a government-owned or controlled corporation may be liable for local franchise tax when it is exercising a franchise and the Local Government Code has withdrawn its prior tax exemption. The controlling inquiry is not simply whether the corporation is government-owned, but whether the levy is directed at a taxable franchise privilege and whether Congress preserved the exemption.

The Court distinguished governmental functions from proprietary functions. While purely governmental instrumentalities may enjoy protection from local taxation, a corporation engaged in commercial or proprietary activities may be treated differently. National Power Corporation generated and sold electricity, operated under a statutory franchise, and earned receipts from that activity. Those features made the local franchise tax applicable.

The ruling also reinforces the constitutional and statutory policy of local fiscal autonomy. Local government units are not merely administrative arms waiting for national allotments. Under the Local Government Code, they are given meaningful taxing authority so they can fund public services, infrastructure, and local development. Section 137, read with Section 151 for cities and Section 193 on withdrawal of exemptions, reflects that policy.

What This Means for Businesses and Individuals

For businesses operating under franchises, this case is a warning against relying on old exemptions without checking the Local Government Code and the current local revenue ordinance. Telecommunications, utilities, infrastructure operators, transport-related companies, and other regulated franchise holders should review whether local franchise taxes apply to their gross receipts.

For government-owned or controlled corporations and public-sector entities engaged in revenue-generating operations, the decision shows that public ownership alone does not automatically defeat local taxation. If the entity performs proprietary functions, collects revenue, and operates under a franchise, local tax exposure may exist unless a clear statutory exemption applies.

For local government units, the ruling strengthens collection authority but also underscores the need for carefully drafted ordinances. A city assessing a franchise tax must still stay within the Local Government Code’s rate limits and must identify the taxable privilege and receipts covered by the assessment.

Facing a Local Tax Assessment? Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help

Businesses and public entities that ignore local franchise tax exposure may face assessments, surcharges, interest, and collection suits from cities or municipalities. In regulated industries, the risk is especially serious because tax disputes can affect permits, cash flow, and continuing operations.

Ablola, Saribong & Gueco advises corporations, franchise holders, and property or business owners on Philippine local taxation, regulatory compliance, and tax litigation before local treasurers, trial courts, and appellate courts. Speak with a Philippine tax lawyer or consult a Makati litigation lawyer through MakatiLawFirm.com or our Makati office for guidance on local tax assessments and franchise tax disputes.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *