RMC No. 62-2003 clarifies that qualifying cash-settled securities swaps in government securities are not deposit substitutes and are not subject to DST.

Banks, quasi-banks, and qualified financial institutions entering into cash-settled securities swap transactions must structure and record those transactions strictly as unconditional, without-recourse transfers of government securities to support non-imposition of Documentary Stamp Tax. RMC No. 62-2003 matters now because it clarifies that a Cash-Settled Securities Swap Transaction, or CSST, is not treated as a deposit substitute and that the transfer of government securities through CSST is not subject to Documentary Stamp Tax, provided the transaction follows the agreed structure and the required accounting entries are strictly observed.

What Changed Under RMC No. 62-2003

RMC No. 62-2003 provides the BIR guidelines for Documentary Stamp Tax evaluation of cash-settled securities swap transactions under the Memorandum of Agreement among the Bangko Sentral ng Pilipinas, Bureau of Treasury, Bankers Association of the Philippines, and Investment Houses Association of the Philippines. The ruling addresses a highly specific but important issue for banks and financial institutions trading government securities: whether a CSST should be taxed as a deposit substitute, a repurchase-type arrangement, or a secondary market transfer of securities.

The central rule is that a CSST is not a deposit substitute. The BIR reasoned that the chief feature of a deposit substitute is borrowing. Without borrowing, there is no deposit substitute. In a CSST, the seller in the spot or forward leg conveys government securities through a straightforward sale. The buyer acquires absolute title, including the right to freely dispose of the securities. The seller does not have primary liability to repay a loan, and the seller is not subsidiarily liable if the issuer of the underlying securities fails to pay. The transaction is therefore treated as a sale without recourse, not as a borrowing or debt instrument.

This distinction is critical for Documentary Stamp Tax purposes. Section 180 of the Tax Code imposes DST on deposit substitute debt instruments. However, because the CSST is not a deposit substitute and does not fall under any other class of documents listed in Section 180, RMC No. 62-2003 states that it is not subject to DST under that provision.

Cash-Settled Securities Swap Transactions Covered by the Circular

A CSST is an agreement entered into between financial institutions, or between financial institutions and the BSP, to simultaneously buy or sell government securities on a spot basis and sell or buy comparable securities at a pre-determined future date and price with the same counterparty. Comparable securities must have the same credit risk, similar cash flow or similar settlement price, and similar maturity and tenor range.

For Treasury Bills, the acceptable deviation from the maturity date of the original security is plus or minus seven days. For Fixed Rate Treasury Notes, the acceptable deviation is plus or minus one month from the maturity date of the original security. These details are important because the DST treatment depends on the transaction remaining within the CSST framework described in the circular.

The underlying or transacted securities for CSST purposes are limited to Philippine peso-denominated government securities issued by the BSP and the Republic of the Philippines and registered with the Registry of Scripless Securities. Only bank-owned or registered securities are eligible as underlying securities. Where the BSP is the counterparty, only Republic of the Philippines securities may be used as underlying securities.

Who Is Most Affected

RMC No. 62-2003 most directly affects BAP-qualified banks, quasi-banking institutions, investment houses, and other financial institutions participating in cash-settled securities swap transactions. It is also relevant to treasury departments, tax compliance teams, in-house counsel, securities operations teams, and accounting departments responsible for government securities trading, RoSS settlement, and Documentary Stamp Tax review.

To participate in CSSTs, financial institutions must be qualified by the Bankers Association of the Philippines and certified to the BIR as having satisfied five criteria. They must be banks or institutions with quasi-banking licenses, have demand deposit accounts with the BSP, be registered RoSS participants and subscribers to an electronic trading platform linked with RoSS, have traders who passed the BAP-sponsored accreditation program, and maintain a sound and effective risk management system certified by the board of directors or equivalent management committee for foreign banks.

Key Compliance Requirements and Transaction Features

The CSST must remain an unconditional sale without recourse. This is the foundation of the DST treatment under RMC No. 62-2003. The spot buyer and forward buyer must have no recourse against the spot seller or forward seller if the issuer fails to redeem or pay on the transacted security. The buyer must acquire absolute title and the right of free disposal. If the transaction is structured in a way that creates primary or subsidiary liability of the seller, the tax analysis may change because the BIRโ€™s ruling depends on the absence of borrowing and recourse.

The standard tenors for CSSTs are one week, two weeks, and one month. The maximum bid or offer spread is fifty basis points, net of value-added tax. The value date is trade date plus one business day, also described as value tomorrow or value spot. The forward price must be fixed by mutual agreement of the parties at the time of the first or spot transaction.

Participating institutions must transmit securities trades through an electronic trading platform linked with RoSS. Manual submission is allowed only where the participant encounters a technical problem in its trading platform confirmed by the service provider to the Bureau of Treasury. Participants must maintain settlement accounts with the BSP, RoSS securities accounts with the Bureau of Treasury, demand deposit accounts with the BSP, and subscriptions with an electronic trading platform linked with RoSS.

Documentary Stamp Tax Treatment

RMC No. 62-2003 confirms two important DST conclusions. First, a CSST is not a deposit substitute because there is no borrowing, no debt instrument, and no recourse against the seller. Second, the conveyance of government securities through CSST, whether in the spot leg or the forward leg, is not subject to Documentary Stamp Tax.

The circular also restates the general rule that conveyance of securities in the secondary market is not subject to DST. It identifies two exceptions: where the security transferred is a quasi-capital instrument under Section 176 of the Tax Code, and where the secondary transfer of the underlying security is wrapped in a package that constitutes a deposit substitute. The BIR explains that this may occur where the transfer document resembles a certificate of assignment or participation with recourse. A CSST falls outside these exceptions because the conveyance is always without recourse.

Accounting Entries Required for DST Exemption

RMC No. 62-2003 requires strict compliance with the accounting entries prescribed in the circular for purposes of exemption from Documentary Stamp Tax. This is a practical compliance point for controllers, tax managers, and treasury accountants. The ruling is not merely about legal form; it also requires the transaction to be booked in a manner consistent with the CSST treatment recognized by the BIR.

The prescribed entries cover the spot date, spot settlement date, and forward date. They distinguish between Treasury Bills and Fixed Rate Treasury Notes. The entries include accounts such as Spot Cash Receivable, Spot Sale of Securities, Spot Purchase of Securities, Spot Cash Payable, Trading Account Securities for Treasury Bills, Trading Account Securities for Fixed Rate Treasury Notes, Prepaid Tax, Due BSP or Cash, Accrued Interest Payable, Accrued Interest Receivable, Forward Purchase of Securities, Forward Cash Payable, Forward Cash Receivable, Forward Sale of Securities, Trading Gain or Loss, Interest Income, Gain on Sale of Securities, Gain on Premium or Discount, and Tax Expense.

The compliance instruction is direct: these accounting entries must be strictly complied with for the purpose of exemption from Documentary Stamp Tax under RMC No. 62-2003. Financial institutions should therefore align treasury, tax, and accounting documentation before relying on the non-DST treatment.

Effective Date and Deadlines

RMC No. 62-2003 took effect immediately. The issuance date is October 8, 2003. No separate transition period, filing deadline, or deferred implementation date is provided in the circular. For covered institutions, the relevant action point is immediate application of the CSST structure, no-recourse documentation, RoSS-linked settlement procedure, and prescribed accounting entries whenever the institution relies on the DST treatment stated in the circular.

Penalties and Risk of Non-Compliance

RMC No. 62-2003 does not prescribe a special penalty, surcharge, interest rate, or separate fine for non-compliance. However, the practical tax risk is significant. If a transaction is not a true CSST, is not without recourse, is booked inconsistently with the required entries, or is structured as a borrowing, repurchase agreement, or deposit substitute in substance, the taxpayer may lose the basis for claiming non-imposition of DST under the circular.

For tax teams searching for Documentary Stamp Tax on securities swaps, DST on government securities transfers, cash-settled securities swap Philippines, CSST tax treatment, or deposit substitute debt instrument DST, the key question is whether the transaction has been structured and documented as an unconditional transfer of comparable government securities without borrowing, without seller recourse, and with full buyer ownership.

Practical Steps for Banks and Financial Institutions

Covered institutions should first confirm that the transaction involves only eligible Philippine peso-denominated government securities registered with RoSS and that the securities are bank-owned or registered securities. If the BSP is the counterparty, the institution should confirm that only Republic of the Philippines securities are used as underlying securities.

Second, the transaction documentation should clearly reflect that both the spot and forward legs are unconditional and without recourse. The buyer should acquire absolute title and free disposal rights over the securities purchased. Any language suggesting a loan, repayment obligation, buyback of the very same debt paper, collateral arrangement, or recourse against the seller should be reviewed carefully.

Third, treasury and accounting teams should verify the applicable tenor, maturity deviation, settlement account arrangements, RoSS-linked trading platform requirements, and the fifty-basis-point maximum bid or offer spread net of VAT. Fourth, the institution should use the accounting entries prescribed in RMC No. 62-2003 and retain records showing that the entries were applied. Finally, tax teams should periodically review CSST documentation to ensure that operational practices remain aligned with the ruling.

How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help

RMC No. 62-2003 is a technical issuance, but its practical consequence is straightforward: properly structured cash-settled securities swap transactions in government securities may be treated as outside Documentary Stamp Tax, while poorly documented or improperly booked transactions may invite tax exposure. Banks, investment houses, and financial institutions should not rely on labels alone. The substance, documentation, settlement mechanics, and accounting treatment must all support the non-DST position.

Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists businesses, financial institutions, and in-house legal and tax teams in reviewing BIR issuances, structuring tax-sensitive commercial transactions, preparing compliance documentation, and responding to BIR assessments. For assistance with Documentary Stamp Tax, securities transactions, BIR compliance, or tax risk review, contact Ablola, Saribong & Gueco through MakatiLawFirm.com.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *