RR No. 3-2004 suspended the 1% withholding tax on payments to agricultural suppliers, but prior withholdings must still be reported and remitted.
Businesses buying agricultural, forest, livestock, poultry, fish, marine, and similar products should stop applying the 1% expanded withholding tax under Section 2.57.2(S) while the suspension remains in force, but they must still report and remit any amounts already withheld before March 1, 2004. RR No. 3-2004 matters immediately to hotels, restaurants, resorts, caterers, food processors, canneries, supermarkets, livestock dealers, poultry dealers, fish and marine product dealers, hardware stores, factories, furniture shops, and other establishments that purchase agricultural products because the BIR suspended the implementation of the withholding requirement until further notice.
What RR No. 3-2004 Changed
RR No. 3-2004 suspended the implementation of Section 2.57.2(S) of Revenue Regulations No. 2-98, as amended by RR No. 17-2003, RR No. 30-2003, and RR No. 1-2004. The suspended provision imposed a 1% withholding tax on income payments made to suppliers of agricultural products.
The rule covered income payments made to agricultural suppliers, including suppliers and sellers of agricultural, forest, and marine food and non-food products, livestock and poultry of a kind generally used as, or yielding or producing foods for human consumption, and breeding stock and genetic materials. The covered examples included hotels, restaurants, resorts, caterers, food processors, canneries, supermarkets, livestock dealers, poultry dealers, fish and marine products dealers, hardware stores, factories, furniture shops, and all other establishments making payments to agricultural suppliers.
The practical effect is straightforward: the 1% withholding tax on income payments to agricultural suppliers is suspended beginning March 1, 2004 and remains suspended until further notice. Businesses should not treat the suspended rule as an active withholding obligation for covered transactions during the suspension period, but they must carefully review transactions made before the suspension took effect because RR No. 3-2004 preserved reporting, remittance, and deductibility consequences for prior withholding.
Who Is Affected by the Suspension
The most directly affected taxpayers are withholding agents that buy agricultural products in the ordinary course of business. This includes food service businesses, hotels, restaurants, resorts, caterers, food processors, canneries, supermarkets, livestock and poultry businesses, fish and marine product dealers, hardware businesses, factories, furniture shops, and other establishments purchasing covered agricultural products from suppliers.
The regulation is also important for agricultural suppliers because the BIR expressly recognized the need for public education, uniform implementation across all regions, and systems to verify that withholding agents properly report and remit taxes actually withheld. Suppliers may be asked by Revenue District Offices or Regional Offices to provide information on transactions with withholding agents for the period from June 1, 2003 to February 29, 2004.
The suspension does not convert prior withholding into an irrelevant matter. Where taxes were withheld before the effectivity of RR No. 3-2004, the withholding agent remains required to report and remit those amounts to the BIR. Businesses that withheld the 1% tax before March 1, 2004 should therefore verify whether the corresponding tax returns and payments were timely filed and paid.
Agricultural Products Covered by the Suspended 1% Rule
The suspended rule was broad. It covered agricultural suppliers of agricultural, forest, and marine food and non-food products, livestock, poultry, and breeding stock or genetic materials. Livestock included cows, bulls and calves, pigs, sheep, goats, and similar animals. Poultry included fowls, ducks, geese, turkey, and similar birds. Marine products included fish and crustaceans, including eels, trout, lobsters, shrimps, prawns, oysters, mussels, clams, shells, and other aquatic products.
Food products remained covered even if they had undergone simple processes of preparation or preservation for the market. These processes included freezing, drying, salting, smoking, and stripping. The suspended rule also covered products using advanced packaging methods such as shrink wrapping in plastics, vacuum packing, tetra-pak, and similar packaging methods.
RR No. 3-2004 also identified polished or husked rice, corn grits, locally produced raw cane sugar, and ordinary salt as agricultural food products. For corporate accountants and tax teams, this matters because the original 1% withholding framework was not limited to fresh produce or raw farm goods. It extended to a wide commercial supply chain involving food products, marine products, livestock, poultry, and certain processed or packaged items.
Marginal Income Earners Were Excluded from the Suspended Rule
The suspended 1% withholding provision contained an exception for income payments to marginal income earners. It referred to the definition under RR No. 11-2000 dated December 12, 2000: individuals not otherwise deriving compensation as employees under an employer-employee relationship, but who are self-employed and deriving gross sales or receipts not exceeding P100,000.00 during any 12-month period.
This distinction remains useful for record review. When a business evaluates prior transactions from June 1, 2003 to February 29, 2004, it should determine whether the supplier was an agricultural supplier covered by the suspended provision or a marginal income earner excluded from the withholding requirement as originally written.
Effective Date and Deadline for Previously Withheld Taxes
RR No. 3-2004 took effect beginning March 1, 2004. The suspension applies from that date and continues until further notice. However, all withholding made on income payments under Section 2.57.2(S) before the effectivity of RR No. 3-2004 must still be reported and remitted by the withholding agent to the BIR on or before the tenth day of the following month for which the amount was withheld.
For taxpayers filing electronically, RR No. 3-2004 states that the deadline for electronic filing shall follow the rules and regulations governing EFPS. This is especially relevant for large taxpayers and other taxpayers required to use electronic filing systems, because the general tenth-day rule must be read together with applicable EFPS filing regulations.
The regulation also ties deductibility to proper withholding compliance. For income payments made before the effectivity of RR No. 3-2004 to be deductible against the withholding agentβs income, the amount required under Section 2.57.2(S) must have been properly withheld, reported, and remitted. In practical terms, a business that failed to withhold, report, or remit the required 1% tax on pre-March 1, 2004 transactions may face issues when claiming the related purchases or expenses as deductible items.
BIR Audit Program for June 1, 2003 to February 29, 2004 Purchases
RR No. 3-2004 directed the BIR to conduct an audit of withholding agents on their purchases of agricultural products from June 1, 2003 to February 29, 2004. Regional Directors and Revenue District Officers were instructed to obtain information from agricultural suppliers in their respective jurisdictions on transactions for which taxes were withheld.
The purpose of the audit program is to determine whether the withheld taxes were properly reported and remitted. If not, the BIR may take the necessary measures to collect the taxes. This is one of the most important compliance points in RR No. 3-2004: although the 1% withholding rule was suspended beginning March 1, 2004, the BIR retained audit and collection authority over taxes actually withheld, or required to be withheld, before the suspension took effect.
Penalties and Risks for Non-Compliance
RR No. 3-2004 does not create a special penalty schedule for the suspended 1% withholding tax. However, it expressly requires reporting and remittance of amounts withheld before March 1, 2004 and authorizes BIR offices to take necessary measures to collect taxes that were not properly reported and remitted.
The most practical risk is loss of deductibility for covered income payments made before the effectivity of the regulation where the required withholding was not properly withheld, reported, and remitted. For businesses with substantial agricultural product purchases, this can affect income tax computations, documentation of cost of sales or expenses, and exposure during withholding tax audits.
Practical Steps for Businesses, CFOs, and Accountants
First, businesses should identify whether they are withholding agents that purchase agricultural products, marine products, livestock, poultry, or related covered goods. The search terms most likely to matter for internal compliance are 1% withholding tax on agricultural suppliers, RR No. 3-2004 agricultural products, BIR withholding tax suppliers of agricultural products, deductibility of purchases with withholding tax, and EFPS deadline for withholding tax remittance.
Second, accounting teams should stop applying the suspended 1% withholding tax for covered income payments beginning March 1, 2004 unless and until a later BIR issuance lifts or modifies the suspension. Internal tax matrices, supplier payment templates, ERP withholding tax codes, and accounts payable checklists should be updated to reflect the suspension.
Third, businesses should review all purchases of agricultural products from June 1, 2003 to February 29, 2004. The review should check whether withholding was made where required, whether amounts withheld were reported, whether payments were remitted to the BIR, and whether supporting documents are available in case of audit.
Fourth, taxpayers should separately identify transactions with marginal income earners, defined as self-employed individuals not deriving compensation as employees and whose gross sales or receipts do not exceed P100,000.00 during any 12-month period. Proper classification may determine whether the original withholding requirement applied to a transaction.
Finally, taxpayers using EFPS should confirm the applicable electronic filing deadlines for the relevant withholding tax returns. RR No. 3-2004 preserves EFPS-specific filing rules and does not replace them with the general tenth-day deadline where electronic filing regulations apply.
How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help
RR No. 3-2004 is a reminder that a suspension of a tax rule does not automatically erase prior compliance exposure. Businesses that buy agricultural products should review their supplier payments, withholding tax records, BIR remittances, and deductibility documentation, especially for the June 1, 2003 to February 29, 2004 audit period identified by the regulation.
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists businesses, CFOs, corporate accountants, in-house counsel, and tax practitioners with BIR compliance reviews, withholding tax audits, supplier payment documentation, EFPS filing issues, and tax risk assessments. For assistance with withholding tax compliance, BIR audits, and Philippine tax advisory matters, contact Ablola, Saribong & Gueco through MakatiLawFirm.com.