RR No. 10-2006 grants conditional tax-free treatment to qualified PSE securities borrowing and lending, subject to BIR-approved MSLA registration and reporting.

Securities borrowing and lending transactions involving Philippine Stock Exchange-listed shares may avoid stock transaction tax, capital gains tax, and documentary stamp tax only if the parties comply with the strict requirements of RR No. 10-2006. The key compliance point is clear: before the first securities borrowing and lending transaction, the Borrower must register a valid Master Securities Lending Agreement with the BIR, pay the Php5,000.00 registration fee, and ensure that the transaction is conducted under the SEC and PSE-supervised SBL framework. Otherwise, the borrowing and return of shares may be treated as taxable sales outside the PSE.

What RR No. 10-2006 Changed for Securities Borrowing and Lending

RR No. 10-2006 prescribed the tax treatment, registration rules, documentation requirements, reporting obligations, and penalty consequences for Securities Borrowing and Lending transactions involving shares of stock or securities listed in the Philippine Stock Exchange. The regulation institutionalized the tax framework for the SBL facility in the Philippine capital market and clarified when the temporary transfer of listed shares from a Lender to a Borrower will not be treated as a taxable sale.

For qualifying SBL transactions, the borrowing and lending of PSE-listed shares, as well as the delivery of collateral to the Lender, are not subject to the stock transaction tax under Section 127 of the Tax Code, capital gains tax under Sections 24(C), 25(A)(3), 28(A)(7)(c), and 28(B)(5)(c), and documentary stamp tax under Section 176 of the Tax Code, as amended by RA 9243. This conditional tax-free treatment applies only if a valid Master Securities Lending Agreement, or MSLA, is executed, registered with, and approved by the BIR; the SBL Program follows SEC rules and regulations; and the SBL Program is administered and supervised by the PSE.

The regulation does not create a blanket tax exemption for every transfer of listed shares described as securities lending. It creates a conditional tax treatment. If the conditions are not met, the borrowing of shares may be treated as a disposal by the Lender and an acquisition by the Borrower, while the return of the shares may be treated as an acquisition by the Lender and a disposal by the Borrower. In that event, the corresponding taxes on the transaction may be imposed.

Who Is Most Affected by RR No. 10-2006

RR No. 10-2006 primarily affects stock brokers, securities dealers, institutional investors, lending agents, custodians, funds, corporations, foreign lenders, borrowers of PSE-listed securities, and other capital market participants using securities borrowing and lending to support settlement obligations, trading strategies, securities financing, collateral pledging, or on-lending arrangements.

A Borrower may be any natural or juridical person who obtains PSE-listed shares or securities from a Lender’s portfolio or investment account under an MSLA for the purposes allowed by the regulation. The Borrower is not required to be registered or accredited by the PSE. A Lender may likewise be any natural or juridical person who lends shares from its own assets or from client assets in the case of a Lending Agent. The regulation expressly contemplates foreign lenders within the definition of Lender.

For CFOs, tax managers, corporate accountants, and compliance officers, the practical concern is whether the company’s securities lending arrangements have a BIR-approved MSLA, whether the transaction is within the permitted SBL purposes, whether the borrowing period does not exceed two years, and whether bi-annual reporting and ledger requirements are being observed. Common search concerns include BIR tax treatment of securities borrowing and lending, MSLA registration BIR requirements, tax-free securities lending Philippines, SBL deemed sale capital gains tax, and PSE securities lending documentary stamp tax.

Key Conditions for Conditional Tax-Free SBL Treatment

The regulation limits covered SBL transactions to shares of stock or securities listed in the PSE, unless declared by the Securities and Exchange Commission to be ineligible for borrowing and lending under an SBL Program. SBL involving securities administered by other exchanges is not covered by this regulation and requires separate rules.

The borrowing period in any SBL agreement cannot exceed two years from the date of execution of the SBL Confirmation Notice. At the end of that period, the Borrower must return equivalent shares of stock or securities of the same type or class, in the same number, and carrying the same rights as the borrowed shares.

A valid MSLA must provide for the Lender’s entitlement to stock rights, dividends, interest, or other benefits accruing to the borrowed shares. These are called Manufactured Dividends or Benefits. The Lender may also retain voting rights over the loaned shares if the parties mutually agree in the MSLA. Receipt of Manufactured Dividends or Benefits is not taxable income to the Lender because it merely represents the dividends or benefits that the Lender would have received had the shares not been loaned. However, payment of the Manufactured Dividends or Benefits by the Borrower is not a tax-deductible expense.

The Borrower must also post collateral in accordance with SEC and PSE rules. Collateral may consist of cash, government securities, equity securities, or letters of credit guaranteed by a bank. Upon expiration of the borrowing period, the Borrower must return the equivalent shares or securities, and the Lender must return the collateral.

Permitted Purposes for Borrowed Shares

The MSLA must limit the use of the borrowed shares or securities to the specified purposes under RR No. 10-2006. These include settlement of a sale of Philippine shares or securities effected in the Philippines, settlement of a future sale whether agreed or not at the time of borrowing, replacement in whole or in part of securities obtained under another SBL agreement, on-lending to another Borrower who has effected another SBL agreement, securities financing and collateral pledging, and other similar or analogous purposes that may be determined by the BIR upon favorable recommendation of the SEC and the PSE.

An MSLA that allows borrowing for both the specified purposes and other unauthorized purposes will not qualify as a valid MSLA. This is a major drafting and compliance issue. The tax treatment depends not only on how the parties label the transaction, but also on whether the agreement strictly confines the use of the borrowed shares to the permitted purposes.

MSLA Registration Requirements and Deadlines

Before entering into the first SBL transaction, the Borrower must provide the BIR with three original or certified true copies of the duly completed MSLA Registration Form, three original or certified true copies of the duly notarized MSLA and addendum if applicable, the prescribed registration fee of Php5,000.00, three original or certified true copies of the Lender’s Notification of Execution of MSLA, and any other documents and information that the BIR may require.

The BIR must return the Borrower’s copy of the MSLA and addendum, endorsed with a registration number and stamped to acknowledge payment of the registration fee, with approval or denial within ten working days from receipt.

Registration must be made with the Law Division of the BIR National Office or such other office as the Commissioner may direct. The MSLA must be registered within two weeks if executed in the Philippines and within one month if executed outside the Philippines. For valid existing MSLAs executed outside the Philippines before the effectivity of the regulation, the Borrower must register the MSLA before entering into the first SBL transaction involving Philippine equity securities.

Only SBL transactions under an MSLA duly registered and approved by the BIR are entitled to conditional tax-free status. Failure to register the MSLA makes the SBL transaction a sale and purchase of the borrowed shares outside the PSE, subject to the corresponding capital gains tax and documentary stamp tax.

When an SBL Transaction Becomes a Deemed Sale

An SBL transaction is deemed a sale and purchase of the borrowed shares or securities when the Borrower fails to return all or part of the borrowed shares at the end of the borrowing period, uses the borrowed shares for purposes other than the specified purposes, defaults under the MSLA in returning the shares, fails to comply with the essential features of a valid MSLA, fails to register or registers the MSLA late, or enters into SBL transactions outside the borrowing period.

Where an SBL is deemed a sale, the sale is treated as having been consummated outside the PSE. The transaction becomes subject to capital gains tax under the applicable provisions of the Tax Code and documentary stamp tax under Section 175 of the Tax Code, as amended by RA 9243. The capital gains tax return, BIR Form No. 1707, must be filed within 30 days following each sale or other disposition of shares of stock. A final consolidated return or adjustment return covering all stock transactions during the taxable year must be filed on or before the fifteenth day of the fourth month following the close of the taxable year.

The tax base for capital gains tax is determined using the closing price of the shares on the day preceding the Specified Day or the actual amount realized, whichever is higher, less the carrying cost or adjusted basis of the securities sold. For documentary stamp tax, the computation is made without any deduction. The Specified Day depends on the violation: where no stock return is made, it is the day following the expiration of the borrowing period; where the shares are used for unauthorized purposes, it is the day the borrowed shares were given to the Borrower; and where the Borrower fails to comply with the Lender’s demand for return, it is the day after that failure to comply.

Recordkeeping and Bi-Annual Reporting Requirements

The Borrower must keep SBL ledgers and other books of account in the form prescribed by the Commissioner of Internal Revenue. The Borrower must enter the required particulars of SBL transactions and stock returns into the ledger, prepare and keep an SBL Transaction Report for each specific SBL transaction, and provide the BIR with copies of the SBL Transaction Report and the accompanying SBL Confirmation Notice.

The ledger must contain the date of borrowing or lending and date of return, names of the Borrower and Lender, reference numbers identifying the SBL transaction, stock return and MSLA, description of the shares or securities borrowed or loaned, quantity and value of the shares or securities, purpose for which the shares or securities were borrowed, and the form, value, and other pertinent information about the collateral.

Bi-annual summary reports of outstanding and liquidated SBL transactions and stock returns must be prepared every six months and filed with the Law Division of the BIR National Office within one month after the end of the covered period. These reports must be accompanied by copies of the SBL Transaction Report and SBL Confirmation Notice covering the specific SBL transactions entered into during the six-month period.

Penalties for Non-Compliance

RR No. 10-2006 applies civil and criminal liabilities for violations of Section 127(A) and Section 175 of the Tax Code, as well as administrative penalties under Sections 248 and 249. A 25% surcharge applies for failure to file a return and pay the tax due on the prescribed date, filing with the wrong internal revenue officer unless otherwise authorized by the Commissioner, failure to pay deficiency tax within the time prescribed in the assessment notice, or failure to pay the full or partial amount of tax due on time.

A 50% surcharge applies in case of willful neglect to file the return within the prescribed period or where a false or fraudulent return is willfully made. Interest is imposed at 20% per annum, or such higher rate as may be prescribed, on unpaid tax from the date prescribed for payment until full payment. Deficiency interest and delinquency interest may also apply.

For each failure to file an information return, statement, or list, keep any required record, or supply information required by the regulation on the prescribed date, the taxpayer may be required to pay Php1,000.00 for each failure, unless the failure is due to reasonable cause and not willful neglect. The aggregate penalty for all such failures during a calendar year may not exceed Php25,000.00.

Practical Steps for Businesses, Brokers, and Tax Teams

Companies and financial institutions participating in securities borrowing and lending should first confirm that the securities involved are listed in the PSE and eligible for SBL under the applicable SEC and PSE framework. They should then review the MSLA to ensure that it contains the essential features required by RR No. 10-2006, including Manufactured Dividends or Benefits, stock return obligations, collateral requirements, a borrowing period not exceeding two years, and permitted purposes only.

The Borrower should register the MSLA before the first SBL transaction, pay the Php5,000.00 registration fee, obtain BIR approval, and coordinate with the Lender to ensure that the Lender’s Notification of Execution of MSLA is properly submitted. Tax teams should calendar the two-week registration period for Philippine-executed MSLAs, the one-month registration period for foreign-executed MSLAs, the ten-working-day BIR action period, the one-month deadline after each six-month reporting period, and the 30-day capital gains tax return deadline if a transaction becomes a deemed sale.

Businesses should also maintain SBL ledgers in a form that can produce legible hard copies, preserve SBL Confirmation Notices, and monitor whether every borrowed share is returned within the borrowing period or upon demand. Any late return, unauthorized use, delayed registration, or transaction outside the borrowing period can convert a tax-free SBL transaction into a taxable deemed sale.

How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help

RR No. 10-2006 is a technical regulation with direct tax exposure for brokers, borrowers, lenders, institutional investors, and companies using PSE-listed securities for financing, settlement, or collateral arrangements. The commercial purpose of securities borrowing and lending may be legitimate, but the tax treatment depends on precise compliance with MSLA registration, permitted-use drafting, BIR reporting, and recordkeeping requirements.

Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists clients with BIR compliance, securities transaction tax analysis, documentary stamp tax exposure, capital gains tax issues, contract review, regulatory filings, and tax risk management for Philippine capital market transactions. For assistance with RR No. 10-2006, MSLA registration, SBL tax treatment, or BIR assessments involving securities transactions, contact Ablola, Saribong & Gueco through MakatiLawFirm.com.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *