RMC No. 37-2007 changes who may sign BIR rulings on tax exemptions, tax incentives, and tax treaty relief, with immediate compliance impact.

Taxpayers seeking BIR confirmation of tax exemptions, tax incentives, or tax treaty relief must now route and evaluate their ruling requests under a higher-level approval structure. RMC No. 37-2007 immediately modifies prior delegations of authority by moving many exemption-related rulings away from Regional Directors and the Assistant Commissioner, Legal Service, and placing approval authority principally with the Deputy Commissioner, Legal and Inspection Group, subject to stated exceptions. For businesses, non-stock entities, embassies, investors, and taxpayers relying on BIR rulings before claiming preferential tax treatment, the practical consequence is clear: the identity of the authorized BIR signatory now matters, and a ruling signed by the wrong level of authority may create compliance risk.

What RMC No. 37-2007 Changed

RMC No. 37-2007 clarifies and modifies the scope of the BIR’s delegation of authority to sign rulings granting or confirming tax exemptions, tax incentives, and tax treaty relief through the ruling process. The issuance was made to clarify and modify the earlier delegation under the April 26, 2007 Memorandum circularized through RMC No. 32-2007.

The main change is the upward movement of signing authority for rulings involving tax exemptions and tax incentives. Rulings that Regional Directors were previously delegated to sign, insofar as they involve the grant or confirmation of tax exemptions or tax incentives, must now be approved and signed by the Assistant Commissioner, Legal Service, unless they fall within specific exceptions. In turn, rulings that the Assistant Commissioner, Legal Service was previously delegated to sign, insofar as they involve the grant or confirmation of tax exemptions, tax incentives, or tax treaty relief, must now be approved and signed by the Deputy Commissioner, Legal and Inspection Group, unless specifically excepted.

This is significant for Philippine tax compliance because many taxpayers rely on BIR confirmatory rulings before applying tax exemptions, preferential tax rates, tax treaty relief, VAT exemptions, and other incentive-based treatments. RMC No. 37-2007 makes clear that the BIR is tightening control over who may grant or confirm these benefits through the ruling process.

Who Is Most Affected by RMC No. 37-2007

The taxpayers most affected are those who request BIR rulings on tax exemption, tax incentives, and tax treaty relief. This includes corporations availing of tax incentives, non-stock non-profit educational institutions confirming tax-exempt status, parties to tax-deferred exchanges, pre-need corporations transferring property to trustees, embassies seeking exemption rulings, and taxpayers applying treaty-based relief or preferential tax treatment.

Large corporations and investors are especially affected where a transaction requires ruling confirmation before implementation. In-house counsel, CFOs, and tax managers should also take note because ruling requests involving exemptions or incentives may require longer internal preparation and more careful routing. Tax practitioners searching for RMC 37-2007 tax exemption rulings, BIR delegation authority tax incentives, BIR tax treaty relief ruling, Regional Director tax exemption ruling, or Deputy Commissioner Legal and Inspection Group ruling should understand that this issuance is about authority, validity, and risk control in the BIR ruling process.

Authority of Regional Directors Under RMC No. 37-2007

RMC No. 37-2007 provides that the delegated authority of Regional Directors to sign rulings involving the grant or confirmation of tax exemptions and tax incentives shall now be approved and signed by the Assistant Commissioner, Legal Service. The circular expressly modifies RMO No. 75-99 and RMC No. 3-2001.

However, Regional Directors retain authority over two categories of requests. First, they may continue to approve requests to use pre-numbered loose-leaf forms, receipts, invoices, and manual books of accounts. Second, they may continue to approve requests for change of accounting period under Section 46 of the Tax Code of 1997, except where the request involves a change of accounting method.

The circular also states that this rule is without prejudice to Revenue Bulletin No. 1-2003 on no-ruling areas. In practical terms, even if a taxpayer routes a request to the proper office, the BIR may still refuse to issue a ruling if the subject falls within no-ruling areas.

Authority of the Assistant Commissioner, Legal Service

RMC No. 37-2007 also modifies the authority of the Assistant Commissioner, Legal Service. Rulings that involve the grant or confirmation of tax exemptions, tax incentives, including tax treaty relief, shall now be approved and signed by the Deputy Commissioner, Legal and Inspection Group. The circular expressly modifies RDAO No. 4-02, RMO No. 30-02, and RMC No. 39-01.

Despite this upward delegation, the Assistant Commissioner, Legal Service continues to approve certain specified requests. These include requests for rulings on tax-deferred exchanges of property for shares under Section 40(C)(2) of the Tax Code of 1997 under appropriate guidelines; rulings on the transfer of property by a pre-need corporation to a trustee in accordance with SEC guidelines on trusts by pre-need companies; rulings on the tax consequence of exchanges of properties made to correct clear mistakes of fact relating to ownership of subdivision lots; embassy requests for tax exemption, whether for the embassy itself or on behalf of its employees; requests for confirmation of tax-exempt status of non-stock non-profit educational institutions; and requests for rulings or certifications on topics covered by RMC No. 2-01 and RMC No. 10-01.

Copies of rulings signed by the Assistant Commissioner, Legal Service under these exceptions must be furnished to the Office of the Deputy Commissioner, Legal and Inspection Group and the Office of the Commissioner immediately upon issuance.

Authority of the Deputy Commissioner, Legal and Inspection Group

The Deputy Commissioner, Legal and Inspection Group is authorized to sign all rulings granting or confirming any tax exemption, tax incentive, or tax treaty relief, including those originating from the VAT Review Committee, provided they are not covered by the stated exceptions and provided further that the rulings are clearly covered by precedent rulings, guidelines, and pertinent issuances.

This means that the Deputy Commissioner’s authority under RMC No. 37-2007 is broad but not unlimited. The ruling must be within established precedent and applicable BIR guidelines. Where a request presents a new legal issue, a novel factual situation, or a ruling of first impression, the matter does not fall within this delegated authority.

Rulings of First Impression Must Be Signed by the Commissioner

RMC No. 37-2007 expressly provides that all rulings of first impression, as defined in Revenue Administrative Order No. 1-03, shall be signed by the Commissioner of Internal Revenue. This is a critical point for complex transactions, new structures, treaty issues, or incentive claims that do not clearly fall within precedent rulings.

The Commissioner may also, motu proprio, reverse, modify, or alter any ruling issued by the Assistant Commissioner, Legal Service or the Deputy Commissioner, Legal and Inspection Group if the Commissioner determines that the ruling is not in accordance with established precedent rulings, pertinent tax laws, or revenue issuances. This may be done at any time after issuance, but only after due notice to the concerned taxpayer and in accordance with Section 246 of the Tax Code of 1997.

Strict Interpretation of Tax Exemption Claims

RMC No. 37-2007 reiterates a fundamental tax rule: all claims and requests for tax exemptions must be strictly evaluated, and any doubt must be resolved in favor of the government. This statement is important because it signals that the BIR will not treat exemption requests as routine administrative confirmations. Taxpayers must present clear legal and factual bases for exemption, incentive, or treaty relief.

For CFOs and corporate accountants, this means that claiming exemption without a strong ruling basis may expose the company to future assessment risk. For tax counsel, this means ruling requests should be supported by complete facts, applicable law, prior rulings where available, and a clear explanation of why the requested relief is not a no-ruling matter and is not a ruling of first impression requiring Commissioner-level action.

Effectivity and Transitional Rule

RMC No. 37-2007 takes effect immediately and remains in force until the Commissioner of Internal Revenue issues an order reverting the delegation to the original designated signatories. The issuance date is May 26, 2007.

There is also a transitory rule. Requests for rulings that had already been elevated to the Assistant Commissioner, Legal Service or the Deputy Commissioner, Legal and Inspection Group for approval under RMC No. 32-2007 before the issuance of RMC No. 37-2007 shall be signed by them respectively. The stated reason is administrative: the signatories indicated in drafts already submitted for approval would not have to be changed again.

Penalties and Compliance Risks

RMC No. 37-2007 does not impose a new numerical penalty, surcharge, interest rate, or filing fee. However, it creates important compliance risk. A taxpayer relying on a ruling involving tax exemption, tax incentive, or tax treaty relief must ensure that the ruling is within the authority of the official who signed it and is consistent with precedent rulings, tax laws, and revenue issuances.

The Commissioner may reverse, modify, or alter certain delegated rulings after due notice if they are not in accordance with established precedent or applicable law. The circular also states that this is without prejudice to administrative sanctions relative to such actions. Although the circular does not prescribe a specific taxpayer penalty, the risk is practical and serious: an exemption or preferential tax treatment may later be questioned if the ruling basis is defective, improperly routed, or inconsistent with controlling issuances.

Practical Steps for Businesses and Taxpayers

Businesses should first identify whether the ruling request involves a tax exemption, tax incentive, or tax treaty relief. If it does, RMC No. 37-2007 should be checked before filing to determine the correct approving authority. A request that appears simple but effectively confirms exemption from tax should not be treated as an ordinary regional ruling matter.

Second, companies should determine whether the request falls under one of the exceptions retained by Regional Directors or by the Assistant Commissioner, Legal Service. For example, a request to use pre-numbered loose-leaf receipts and books of accounts remains with the Regional Director, while certain Section 40(C)(2) tax-deferred exchange rulings remain with the Assistant Commissioner, Legal Service under appropriate guidelines.

Third, taxpayers should assess whether the matter is clearly covered by precedent rulings and existing guidelines. If the matter is novel, it may be a ruling of first impression that must be signed by the Commissioner. This distinction should be addressed directly in the ruling request to avoid delay or later challenge.

Fourth, applicants should prepare complete documentary support. Because the circular requires strict evaluation of exemption claims and resolves doubt in favor of the government, ruling requests should not rely on conclusory statements. They should clearly state the factual background, statutory basis, applicable revenue issuances, prior rulings if relevant, and the exact relief being requested.

Finally, businesses should maintain a compliance file containing the request, supporting documents, issued ruling, proof of receipt, and any later correspondence. This is especially important where the ruling supports a tax position used in returns, financial statements, tax treaty relief applications, incentive availment, VAT treatment, or withholding tax treatment.

How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help

RMC No. 37-2007 is a reminder that tax exemption, tax incentive, and tax treaty relief claims require more than a favorable legal theory. They require proper routing, complete support, and a ruling request that fits within the correct level of BIR authority. For businesses, the cost of an improperly handled ruling request may be delay, denial, or future assessment exposure.

Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists corporations, business owners, CFOs, accountants, and in-house counsel in preparing BIR ruling requests, tax exemption confirmations, treaty relief positions, incentive documentation, and compliance strategies. For assistance with RMC No. 37-2007, BIR tax rulings, tax exemption applications, and tax controversy risk management, visit MakatiLawFirm.com.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *