RMO No. 19-2007 revised BIR compromise penalty rules for non-fraud NIRC violations and required criminal referral for fraud or refusal to settle.

Businesses facing BIR examinations, tax mapping findings, apprehension slips, or demand letters must treat compromise penalties as a separate criminal-liability settlement issue, not as part of the deficiency tax assessment. RMO No. 19-2007 took effect immediately on August 8, 2007 and requires revenue officers to apply a consolidated revised schedule of compromise penalties for National Internal Revenue Code violations that do not involve fraud, while excluding fraudulent acts from compromise treatment and routing them for criminal action.

What Changed Under RMO No. 19-2007

RMO No. 19-2007 prescribed the Consolidated Revised Schedule of Compromise Penalties for violations of the National Internal Revenue Code. Its central change is uniformity: BIR officers are directed to follow strictly the amounts stated in the revised schedule for criminal violations of the NIRC that do not involve fraudulent acts. The order aligns the BIR schedule with the penalties under the NIRC of 1997 and updates the format to reflect the Code section, the nature of the violation, the criminal penalty imposed under the NIRC, and the amount of compromise penalty.

The issuance also made an important boundary clear. Certain acts or violations commonly used as means of tax evasion were deleted from the coverage of compromise penalties because they meet the definition of fraudulent acts. In practical terms, a taxpayer cannot assume that every NIRC violation may be settled by paying a compromise penalty. Where the BIR treats the matter as fraud, the case must be referred for the institution of the appropriate criminal action.

Who Is Most Affected

The taxpayers most affected are businesses and individuals dealing with BIR compliance examinations, tax mapping, audit findings, apprehension slips, and possible criminal violations under the NIRC. This includes corporations, SMEs, sole proprietors, professionals, withholding agents, VAT taxpayers, percentage tax taxpayers, and other registered taxpayers whose compliance lapses may carry criminal consequences under the Tax Code.

Accounting departments and CFOs should pay particular attention because compromise penalties often appear during practical BIR enforcement situations, including registration, invoicing, bookkeeping, withholding tax, return filing, and other compliance deficiencies. The order also matters to resident taxpayers and non-residents because it expressly provides supplemental guidelines covering both groups.

Key Compliance Rule: Compromise Penalties Must Follow the Revised Schedule

For non-fraud criminal violations of the NIRC, the BIR officer handling the case must apply the Revised Schedule of Compromise Penalties. The compromise penalty should not differ from the prescribed amount unless the deviation is duly approved by the Commissioner of Internal Revenue, the concerned Deputy Commissioner, or, in proper cases, the Regional Director.

RMO No. 19-2007 does not state a new tax rate, surcharge rate, interest rate, or filing deadline. Its operative compliance change is procedural and enforcement-based: the BIR must use the revised schedule uniformly, and taxpayers must understand that the amount suggested is tied to possible criminal exposure rather than the basic deficiency tax assessment.

Separate Treatment From Deficiency Tax, Surcharge, and Interest

One of the most important audit-handling rules in RMO No. 19-2007 is that compromise penalties must be itemized in the assessment notice or demand letter, but they should not form part of the assessment notice that reflects deficiency basic tax, surcharge, and interest. Instead, the compromise penalty should appear in a separate assessment notice or demand letter as the amount suggested to the taxpayer in lieu of criminal prosecution.

This distinction matters in BIR audit strategy. Deficiency tax, surcharge, and interest are civil tax liabilities. The compromise penalty, as described in the order, is a suggested settlement amount for criminal liability. Businesses responding to BIR assessments should therefore review whether the BIR has separated the civil tax assessment from the compromise penalty demand and whether the alleged violation is properly categorized as non-fraud or fraud.

Penalties and Criminal Exposure for Non-Compliance

RMO No. 19-2007 clarifies that compromise penalties are only suggested settlement amounts for criminal liability. They may not be imposed or exacted from the taxpayer as if they were ordinary tax liabilities. However, this does not make them risk-free. If the taxpayer refuses to pay the suggested compromise penalty, the violation must be referred to the appropriate office for criminal action.

For cases involving fraud, the rule is stricter. Revenue officers must refer the case to the concerned division having jurisdiction for the institution of the corresponding criminal action. The practical consequence is that fraudulent tax conduct is outside the ordinary compromise-penalty settlement route contemplated by the order.

Apprehension Slips and Compromise Offers

Where Apprehension Slips have been issued, all offers of compromise must be made using the form prescribed in Annex B of the order. This is relevant to taxpayers who receive field enforcement documents from the BIR and later seek to settle the criminal aspect of the violation. A business should avoid informal or undocumented settlement discussions and ensure that any offer of compromise follows the required form and authority level.

The order also preserves BIR discretion to accept a compromise amount higher than the amount in the schedule. A lower compromise offer may be accepted only after approval by the Commissioner of Internal Revenue or the concerned Deputy Commissioner, Assistant Commissioner, or Regional Director. This means taxpayers seeking a lower amount need a properly justified request and the correct level of BIR approval.

What Businesses Should Do Now

First, companies should separate civil tax exposure from criminal compromise exposure when reviewing BIR notices. A demand for deficiency tax, surcharge, and interest should be analyzed independently from any compromise penalty stated as settlement in lieu of criminal prosecution.

Second, taxpayers should identify whether the alleged violation is treated as non-fraud or fraud. Non-fraud criminal violations may fall within the revised schedule of compromise penalties. Fraud cases, however, should be expected to move toward criminal referral rather than ordinary compromise treatment.

Third, businesses should verify whether the compromise penalty amount follows the prescribed schedule and whether any deviation has the required approval. If the amount is lower or higher than the schedule, the taxpayer should ask whether the proper approving authority has acted on the deviation.

Fourth, taxpayers with Apprehension Slips should ensure that compromise offers are made using the required form. This is especially important for field enforcement cases, tax mapping incidents, and other situations where the BIR may later elevate the matter for criminal action.

Common search terms for this issue include RMO No. 19-2007 compromise penalties, BIR compromise penalty schedule, NIRC criminal violations compromise penalty, BIR apprehension slip compromise, and BIR tax evasion fraud criminal referral.

How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help

Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists businesses, officers, accountants, and in-house counsel in responding to BIR assessments, demand letters, compromise penalty issues, apprehension slips, and potential criminal tax exposure. Our Makati-based tax and business law team can help determine whether the alleged violation is properly compromiseable, whether the BIR has followed the correct procedure, and how to respond without unnecessarily escalating the matter.

For assistance with BIR compromise penalties, tax audit response, NIRC compliance, or potential criminal tax exposure, contact Ablola, Saribong & Gueco through MakatiLawFirm.com.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *